Better Enforcement Is Essential, but May Be Inadequate: Findings of a Survey on the Factors Affecting Payment of Speeding Fines in Cape Town, South Africa

Abstract

While a large body of research has established that effective enforcement of speeding laws is essential for reducing the economic and social costs of road accidents, some studies have suggested that interventions aimed at moral beliefs about speeding and peer-related and other social contagion effects may be important complements to law enforcement activities. This article presents tentative evidence of the complementary nature of interventions to influence moral beliefs and steps to strengthen the enforcement of traffic laws. It does this by presenting and discussing the results of a survey that elicited information about the attitudes of motorists in Cape Town regarding speeding fines and aspects of the administration of traffic laws in South Africa. The self-reported fine-paying behaviour of the respondents correlates with instrumental factors shaped by the effectiveness of enforcement actions (e.g., compliance and monetary costs) as well as normative factors influenced by the moral beliefs of drivers and their social groups as well as the perceived legitimacy of traffic laws and officials. Regression results also provide evidence of a statistically significant relationship between the respondents’ self-reported fine-paying behaviour and their moral beliefs regarding payment of speeding fines.

Nudging People to Pay Their Parking Fines on Time. Evidence from a Cluster-Randomized Field Experiment

“…People's compliance with municipal parking regulations helps reduce road accidents, emissions and traffic congestion, and stimulates a better, more inclusive urban environment (Marsden, 2006). Well-designed parking policies increase the overall safety, health, viability, and attractiveness of inner-city residential and commercial areas (Bantjes et al, 2021;Du Plessis et al, 2020;Makowsky & Stratmann, 2011), and are an important source of revenue for the local administration (Lofstrom & Raphael, 2016;Marsden, 2006;Piehl & Williams, 2010;Su, 2020). For these policies to work effectively, people have to accept them and pay their fines correctly (Manville & Pinski, 2021;Tyler, 2006aTyler, , 2006b.…”