Better with age: financial reporting quality in family firms

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to contribute to the literature on financial reporting quality (FRQ) within family firms (FFs), assessing whether longevity can determine a different propensity to earning management (EM) behaviors. Design/methodology/approach The sample, composed by Italian and Brazilian listed family (and non-family) firms, is segregated into old and young. For each subsample, unsigned discretionary accruals are calculated, using two different EM models. A linear regression model is then proposed, together with some robustness tests, to confirm the research hypothesis. Findings The outcome is that, within FFs, the entrenchment effect seems to be diminishing with the company’s age, up to become lower than the alignment effect. With some caveat, research also demonstrates that old FFs are more propense to supply higher FRQ than any other subsample group. Research limitations/implications The authors demonstrated that, in terms of EM decision process, FFs become virtuous just with time. More research is needed to evaluate the impact of the share and management control separately and to analyze different generation segmentation. Practical implications This paper could help non-family stakeholders, as it shows that different company types (family vs non-family), at a different stage of the life-cycle (young vs old) have a different attitude toward FRQ. On the other hand, family owners could exploit the longevity as a value driver. Originality/value This paper suggests that agency theory and socio-emotional theory are complementary in explaining the family control role in earnings management decisions. The study also contributes to the debate of FF homogeneity and on risk behavior in FFs, often portrayed as having a patient capital.

Creative Accounting Determination and Financial Reporting Quality: The Integration of Transparency and Disclosure

“…Other researchers also observed a positive effect of the ownership structure on firm performance [50]. Additionally, the ownership structure positively affected financial reporting quality [51]. The correlation between financial reporting quality and ownership structure has been studied in many types of research.…”

Illuminating the shadows: a systematic review of earnings management practices in family-owned enterprises and future research directions

“…Figure 2 shows the geographical distribution of sample data. According to this distribution, the majority of studies were conducted at the country level, with 11 being cross-country studies (e.g., Attig et al, 2020;Tommasetti et al, 2020;S aenz Gonz alez and Garc ıa-Meca, 2014). Cross-country studies offer a more in-depth understanding of the relationship, compared to a single-country perspective.…”

The Moderating Impact of the Audit Committee on Creative Accounting Determination and Financial Reporting Quality in Iraqi Commercial Banks

“…The agency theory suggested that managers, who represent shareholders often indulge in creative accounting practices to maximize shareholder wealth. This theory stated that control mechanisms need to be carried out for protection of the shareholders against any conflict that affects their profit (Tommasetti et al 2019). Hence, an information asymmetry is noted due to the profit conflicts occurring between the shareholders and managers.…”