Beyond gender mainstreaming: transforming humanitarian action, organizations and culture

Abstract

The United Nations and major humanitarian organizations have made policy commitments to promote gender equality and empower women and girls. This study assesses the extent to which humanitarian responses have met these commitments based on reviews of gender mainstreaming, textual analysis of policy and program cycle documents, and interviews with humanitarian actors. The analysis reveals that while gender mainstreaming may raise awareness and make fixes at the margins, its focus has been limited to altering internal processes rather than emphasizing results for women and men and girls and boys. Our study also analyzes the cultural and institutional context in which gender mainstreaming takes place. The culture of humanitarian organizations has been characterized as hierarchical and driven by a short-term crisis response with a distinctly macho style of functioning, which is misaligned with gender mainstreaming. We propose replacing gender mainstreaming with a results-focused approach rooted in behavioral science that uses evidence of the conscious and non-conscious drivers of human behavior to address problems, alongside other efforts to change the internal culture of humanitarian organizations.

Engaging Community Health Workers (CHWs) in Africa: Lessons from the Canadian Red Cross supported programs

“…They noted that proactive efforts should be made to ensure that women CHWs are not burdened with additional responsibilities but rather provided with opportunities for influence and decision-making. A recent article suggests that existing humanitarian culture and behaviour may be a barrier to gender mainstreaming, particularly for promoting gender equality and outline “saviour mentality and macho culture of a male-dominated field, a tolerance for abuse, and the short-term nature of crisis response” as main obstacles [ 48 ]. In contexts where male dominance prevails, it is crucial to challenge gender norms and promote equal participation and representation.…”

Greener through gender: What climate mainstreaming can learn from gender mainstreaming

“…Narrow conceptualizations of gender fail to account for other social identities (e.g., race, age, sexuality), constraining inclusiveness (Lamprell & Braithwaite, 2017). Overall, gender mainstreaming has been characterized as slow and inconsistent (Gupta et al, 2023).…”