Beyond solidarity, reciprocity and altruism: moral capital as a unifying concept in intergenerational support for older people

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to review, contrast and synthesise several major intellectual streams that have guided theoretical development and empirical research in the area of intergenerational family support to older people: (a) normativeintegrative approaches that focus on cohesion between family members based on bonds of solidarity and norms of filial obligation, and (b) transactional approaches that are primarily concerned with identifying motives for resource transfers across generational lines. We propose the concept of moral capital -defined as the stock of internalised social norms that obligate children to care for and support their older parents -the transmission of which lies at the intersection of self-interest (for parents) and altruism (for children). Using data from a multigenerational family study, we present an empirical analysis showing that a strong positive correspondence in the filial obligations of adult children and their older mothers -arguably the result of intergenerational transmission -elevated the supportive behaviour of children. We suggest that moral capital may be a useful unifying concept that bridges disciplinary and theoretical divides in the study of intergenerational transfers to elderly people by helping resolve the paradox of how self-interest and selflessness can co-exist within families.

All in the family: The link between kin network bridging and cardiovascular risk among older adults

“…The findings from this study suggest that ties among one's closest children and sibling(s) may also be a significant source of intergenerational kin support, beyond traditionally considered dyadic ties. When adult children do not assume the same ties with family as do their parents, and older adults may feel less accomplished in transferring norms around family solidarity across generational lines (Silverstein, Conroy, and Gans 2012). As extensive prior work establishes that siblings - as well as adult children - are significant sources of emotional and instrumental aide throughout the lifespan, often as life-long social network members (Cicirelli 2013), an older adult’s social support system may be also significantly less coordinated when the sibling and child are not tied to one another.…”

The effect of social capital and altruism on seniors' revisit intention to social network sites for tourism-related purposes

“…Reported levels of social support (i.e., altruism) are associated with lower morbidity, whereas levels of receiving are not, and these relations held even when (a) socioeconomic status, education, marital status, age, gender, ethnicity, and (b) absolute network size and activity limitation are controlled (Brown, Consedine, & Magai, 2005). When supporting seniors, moral capital exists in the family between strategic investments by parents and the altruism of children, which represents two sides of the same intergenerational coin (Silverstein, Conroy, & Gans, 2012). Altruistic attitudes make unique contributions to the maintenance of life satisfaction, positive affect, and other well-being outcomes in later life (Kahana et al, 2013).…”

Promoting LatinX Generativity: Cultural Humility and Transformative Complicity Through Geriatric Teams

“…Silverstein, Conroy, and Gans (2012) emphasized moral capital as transgenerationally transmitted altruistic values through social institutions such as schools, churches, and social service agencies. These can help children and family members develop norms of filial responsibility (p. 1259).…”