Beyond the black box: promoting mathematical collaborations for elucidating interactions in soil ecology

Abstract

Understanding soil systems is critical because they form the structural and nutritional foundation for plants and thus every terrestrial habitat and agricultural system. In this paper, we encourage increased use of mathematical models to drive forward understanding of interactions in soil ecological systems. We discuss several distinctive features of soil ecosystems and empirical studies of them. We explore some perceptions that have previously deterred more extensive use of models in soil ecology and some advances that have already been made using models to elucidate soil ecological interactions. We provide examples where mathematical models have been used to test the plausibility of hypothesized mechanisms, to explore systems where experimental manipulations are currently impossible, or to determine the most important variables to measure in experimental and natural systems. To aid in the development of theory in this field, we present a table describing major soil ecology topics, the theory previously used, and providing key terms for theoretical approaches that could potentially address them. We then provide examples from the table that may either contribute to important incremental developments in soil science or potentially revolutionize our understanding of plant–soil systems. We challenge scientists and mathematicians to push theoretical explorations in soil systems further and highlight three major areas for the development of mathematical models in soil ecology: theory spanning scales and ecological hierarchies, processes, and evolution.

Differential Responses of the Catalytic Efficiency of Ammonia and Nitrite Oxidation to Changes in Temperature

“…While environmental change predictions and climate models have focused on plant effects and C sequestration, the evaluation of environmental changes on microbial physiology has lagged behind or simply been treated as a “black box” ( Shade et al, 2009 ; McGuire and Treseder, 2010 ; Treseder et al, 2012 ; Bennett et al, 2019 ). Nitrifying microorganisms are an important group that controls the size and composition of inorganic N pools available to plants ( Ward, 2011 ).…”

Overcoming the Challenges to Enhancing Experimental Plant Biology With Computational Modeling

“…Mathematical modeling is the process of describing complex systems in a logically consistent and explicit manner using a quantitative framework (Nijhout et al, 2015 ). Such models can generate testable hypotheses by relating possible mechanisms and relationships to observable, measurable phenomena (Bennett et al, 2019 ). In addition, models are used to identify non-intuitive relationships, emergent properties, and the conditions under which phenomena arise.…”

What to expect from alternative management strategies to conserve seabirds? Hints from a dynamic modelling framework applied to an endangered population

“…This is especially relevant whenever using generic PVA software and when detailed information on the spatial distribution of species or habitat requirements is not available (Chaudhary & Oli, 2020). In this instance, some authors recommend developing tailor‐made applications for the particular purpose and data available (Bennett et al ., 2019; Lucas, 2020). Dynamic modelling frameworks underpinned by bio‐ecological information are especially promising (Anderson et al ., 2018; Miller et al ., 2019).…”