Beyond the income inequality hypothesis and human health: a worldwide exploration

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: To analyze whether the relationship between income inequality and human health is mediated through social capital, and whether political regime determines differences in income inequality and social capital among countries. METHODS: Path analysis of cross sectional ecological data from 110 countries. Life expectancy at birth was the outcome variable, and income inequality (measured by the Gini coefficient), social capital (measured by the Corruption Perceptions Index or generalized trust), and political regime (measured by the Index of Freedom) were the predictor variables. Corruption Perceptions Index (an indirect indicator of social capital) was used to include more developing countries in the analysis. The correlation between Gini coefficient and predictor variables was calculated using Spearman's coefficients. The path analysis was designed to assess the effect of income inequality, social capital proxies and political regime on life expectancy. RESULTS: The path coefficients suggest that income inequality has a greater direct effect on life expectancy at birth than through social capital. Political regime acts on life expectancy at birth through income inequality. CONCLUSIONS: Income inequality and social capital have direct effects on life expectancy at birth. The "class/welfare regime model" can be useful for understanding social and health inequalities between countries, whereas the "income inequality hypothesis" which is only a partial approach is especially useful for analyzing differences within countries.

Income Inequality, Socioeconomic Deprivation and Depressive Symptoms among Older Adults in Mexico

“…In one of the most explored theoretical models, inequality generates social corrosion, corruption and alterations in social capital, thereby creating a hostile social environment, which produces a risk to overall health, including mental health [60]. However, these pathways have not been fully elucidated and, therefore, this constitutes a promising field of research.…”

Effect of Income Inequality on Health Status in a Selection of Middle and Low Income Countries

“…The results of this study suggest that income inequality has a negative effect on health and environmental quality. Idrovo et al (2010) in a cross-country study in 110 countries showed that social capital and income inequality have a direct effect on life expectancy. Elgar (2010) in a study examined the relationship between income inequality and public health in 33 countries.…”

Physical environment and life expectancy at birth in Mexico: an eco-epidemiological study

“…Some effects of income inequality on health have been extensively explored within the "income inequality hypothesis" framework. Other macro-determinants require more empirical studies, following alternative approaches 6 .…”