Biased Self‐Perception Tendencies: Self‐Enhancement/Self‐Diminishment and Leader Derailment in Individualistic and Collectivistic Cultures

Abstract

Self–other agreement (SOA) discrepancies are commonly interpreted as a lack of self‐awareness. The consistent display of such discrepancies could be considered a behavioral manifestation of biased self‐perception. In extreme forms, we propose that this bias can be viewed as a form of dark personality. Using archival data from a multisource instrument, we examine the derailment implications of self‐enhancement (i.e. overrating) and the opposite tendency, self‐diminishment (i.e. underrating), in collectivistic (Taiwan, China, South Korea) and individualistic (United States of America) cultures. In particular, we examine whether individuals whose biased self‐perception tendencies violate cultural norms are perceived as more likely to derail. In both culture types, individuals with small SOA discrepancies and high ratings on managerial competence were perceived as less likely to derail. However, the implications of self‐enhancement and self‐diminishment were culturally contingent. Self‐enhancement was not related to derailment in individualistic cultures, but in collectivistic cultures, which endorse the norm of modesty, individuals who overrate (self‐enhance) are perceived by their boss as more likely to derail. Substantial underrating (self‐diminishment) was also related to higher perceived likelihood of derailment in collectivistic cultures, but in individualistic cultures, some evidence suggests that self‐diminishment may be related to decreased perceptions of derailment.

How displaying empathic concern may differentially predict career derailment potential for women and men leaders in Australia

“…Consistent with studies in the past decade (for instance, Cullen, Gentry, & Yammarino, 2015;Gentry & Shanock, 2008;Graves, Ohlott, & Ruderman, 2007) scores from the 40 items from the BENCHMARKS assessment used to measure the five behaviors that limit or stall a person's career (i.e., problems with interpersonal relationships, difficultly building and leading teams, difficulty changing and adapting, failure in meeting business goals and objectives, and too narrow functional orientation) were averaged together to assess career derailment potential operationalized as behaviors limiting or stalling a person's career. These items in total have been shown to "differentiate promotable managers from nonpromotable managers" (Lyness & Judiesch, 2008, p. 793).…”

Discrepancies in Leader and Follower Ratings of Transformational Leadership: Relationship with Organizational Culture in Mental Health

“…For example Cullen et al (2015) found that self-enhancement and self-diminishment were dependent on culture. The Global Leadership and Organizational Behavior Effectiveness (GLOBE) project has documented issues in leadership from 62 societies and 27 European societies (House et al 2013).…”

Authentic leadership and thriving among nurses: the mediating role of empathy

“…This is because self‐reported ratings tend to be biased (Cullen et al . ). Moreover, since we examined an outcome among nurses, the perception of the nurses managers' empathy of the nurses has a stronger impact on this outcome in comparison with that of the nurse managers themselves.…”