BIM-based design decisions documentation using design episodes, explanation tags, and constraints

Abstract

The process of designing a building involves producing design concepts while fulfilling various requirements and regulations. Furthermore, during the project's life-cycle, multiple experts from multiple domains collaborate in developing the different partial models, including architectural, structural, and HVAC among others. Accordingly, clearly communicating the rationale behind design decisions is crucial for developing regulatory compliant designs that also fit the owner’s needs. The developed designs are the main deliverables exchanged and handed over. However, these deliverables do not include any explanation of design intentions or documentation of design decisions. Communication among parties and reuse of knowledge are hindered by the absent explanation of existing design. To overcome this deficiency, this paper proposes a methodology for digitally documenting design decisions, incorporating their intention and rationale. Architectural concepts and evaluation criteria are represented in the form of explanation tags as well as spatial and semantic constraints, which are assigned to the individual model elements and properties. Additionally, to document how design decisions fulfill owner requirements and regulatory documents, natural language processing (NLP) is employed to facilitate querying those documents and then the individual requirements are linked to specific elements, properties, and constraints. To evaluate the proposed methodology, a prototype was implemented as a plugin inside a BIM- Authoring tool and multiple real-world use cases are discussed.

Calculation of embodied GHG emissions in early building design stages using BIM and NLP-based semantic model healing

“…Nevertheless, automated matching of LCA and IFC data on the element level using NLP has not been developed yet [2]. Finally, Zahedi et al proposed an NLP approach for documenting design decisions by searching building codes and request for proposal documents [29].…”

Assessment of a Decision-Making Model for Monitoring the Success of a Project for Smart Buildings

“…In the same way, the contractors transfer most BIM operations responsibilities to an external provider, which costs more than 80 percent of the BIM budget. Despite the fact that contractors may choose BIM operations from an external provider [41], which takes up the BIM budget amongst 80 percent as well as 20 percent. On the other hand, making BIM outsourcing decisions effectively remains difficult.…”

The Green BIM Process Model for Efficient Information Exchange in Sustainable Building Design

“…Thus, the construction industry remains fragmented, primarily caused by the lack of collaboration among practitioners (Kim et al, 2020). This results in a situation where the industry tends to exhibit a "lonely" BIM level 1 maturity, rather than the desired cooperative BIM level 2 maturity that is recommended in the BIM standard (Zahedi et al, 2022). According to Zanni et al (2020), this can be identi ed as the main factor contributing to the performance gap that exists between the simulated sustainability performance of buildings and their actual operational sustainability performance.…”