The
rapid and efficient conversion of carbon dioxide (CO2)
to carbon monoxide (CO) is an ongoing challenge. Catalysts based
on iron-porphyrin cores have emerged as excellent electrochemical
mediators of the two proton + two electron reduction of CO2 to CO, and many of the design features that promote function are
known. Of those design features, the incorporation of Brønsted
acids in the second coordination sphere of the iron ion has a significant
impact on catalyst turnover kinetics. The Brønsted acids are
often in the form of hydroxyphenyl groups. Herein, we explore how
the acidity of an ancillary 2-hydroxyphenyl group affects the performance
of CO2 reduction electrocatalysts. A series of meso-5,10,15,20-tetraaryl
porphyrins were prepared where only the functional group at the 5-meso
position has an ionizable proton. A series of cyclic voltammetry (CV)
experiments reveal that the complex with −OMe positioned para to the ionizable −OH shows the largest CO2 reduction rate constants in acetonitrile solvent. This is
the least acidic −OH of the compounds surveyed. The turnover
frequency of the −OMe derivative can be further improved with
the addition of 4-trifluoromethylphenol to the solution. In contrast,
the iron-porphyrin complex with −CF3 positioned
opposite the ionizable −OH shows the smallest CO2 reduction rate constants, and its turnover frequency is less enhanced
with the addition of phenols to the reaction solutions. The origin
of this effect is rationalized based on kinetic isotope effect experiments
and density functional calculations. We conclude that catalysts with
weaker internal acids coupled with stronger external acid additives
provide superior CO2 reduction kinetics.