Tarragona, October 23 th 2015Dear Prof. Advincula:We send our revised manuscript entitled: Multifunctional allyl-terminated hyperbranched poly(ethylenimine) as component of new thiol-ene/thiol-epoxy materials, to be accepted for publication in Reactive and Functional Polymers.We have included practically all the suggestions and corrections made by the reviewers and some answers to their questions have been included in the answer to the reviewer comments file.Looking forward to hearing from you, I remain. We agree and we have performed changes in the paragraph orders.3) Can you know the reaction rate of each scheme in scheme 3?
It is not possible to measure both reaction rates, but the first is predominant over the second. We have decided to remove the second mechanism of thiol-epoxy condensation in Scheme 3, since the first equation is much more favorable than the second one. This is because the ammonium salt is much more acidic than the thiol, and then the formation of the thioether alcohol should take place only by the first equation.4) Please discuss the basicity of imidazole and so on. This information of base is important in this study.
If we look to the pKa of the ammonium and imidazolium cations we realize that amines are more basic than imidazole (pKa of alkyl ammonium is ~10, whereas pKa of imidazolium is ~7). However, the problem arises from the amount of PEIene in the formulation. When the proportion of PEIene is high it catalyzes the second step in which a base is needed and thiol-epoxy reaction takes place overlapped. On the contrary, when the proportion of PEIene is low, then the basicity of the reaction medium is not enough to reach a complete thiol-epoxy conversion and 1-methylimidazole should be added.
5) Can you get mobility of electron in photo induced polymerization?No, there is no electron mobility. As the radical is formed it reacts instantaneously accordingly to a "click" reaction.6) Can you get turn over number in Scheme 2.The number of cycles is the same than the number of reacting molecules. It is a polycondensation mechanism and not a polyaddition reaction. Thiol-ene is a "click" reaction that occurs in a quantitative way.
7)In scheme 3, left side is same. combine it and only right side should be different scheme.
Detailed Response to ReviewersWe have suppressed the second mechanism as commented above.Reviewer #2: Authors synthesized an allyl terminated hyperbranched poly(ethyleneimine). The multifunctional macromonomer has been used as -ene component in thiol-ene/thiol-epoxy curing formulations.Authors need to address the followings to meet publication requirements:1. Please add captions for schemes and figures, respectively.We apologize, but we forgot to add the file with the figure and scheme captions to the manuscript 2. Formats of Table 1, Table 2 and Table 3 are not consistent with each other. Please correct them.
It is true. They have been corrected.3. There is a lack of discussion on how authors' work in comparison to others. It is important for authors to address this. formula...