The Avalon Peninsula, Newfoundland, Canada, defined as the type zone of Avalonia is believed to have been impacted by several orogenetic and deformation events since the Neoproterozoic. Previous studies determined the lowest degree of metamorphism reached in the successions was of the prehnite-pumpellyite or greenschist facies. We sampled and measured thirteen clastic sedimentary sections ranging from the late Ediacaran to the Early Ordovician and analysed the illite “crystallinity” of 331 samples using the Kübler index. Our results show diagenetic zones occur related to lithology, age and burial depth, respectively, and regional setting. Samples adjacent to the fault zones bounding the Holyrood Horst experienced among the highest degree of metamorphism (anchizone) in the study area. The lowest degree of thermal alteration occurs in the high stratigraphic sections at the centre of the horst structure where shallow diagenetic conditions are preserved. Fault zones, most probably active during the Acadian Orogeny, may have served as potential paths for hot fluids in bounding areas of the horst, whereas the centre of the horst remained almost unaffected by any metamorphic overprint. The thermal impact decreases from the Bonavista Peninsula to the study area from greenschist facies to anchizonal and diagenetic. The study area experienced lower metamorphic conditions than major regions of Avalonia south of the study area on the mainland of New Brunswick and Maine and eastwards in Europe. The thermal impact is in part consistent with a few other areas of Avalonia, such as the Mira terrane and the Antigonish Highlands in Nova Scotia.