Among the amino acids, cysteine stands apart based on its highly reactive sulfur group. In general, cysteine is underrepresented in proteins. Yet when present, the features of cysteine often afford unique function. We have shown previously that a cysteine within the ATPase domain of yeast BiP (Kar2) serves as a sensor of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) redox environment [1, 2]. Under conditions of increased oxidant (oxidative stress) this cysteine becomes oxidized, changing Kar2 from an ATP-dependent foldase to an ATP-independent holdase. We were struck by the high degree of conservation for this cysteine between BiP orthologs, and we sought to determine how cysteine substitution impacts Kar2 function. We observed no single amino acid replacement is capable of recreating the range of functions that can be achieved by wild-type Kar2 with its cysteine in either the unmodified or oxidized states. However, we were able to generate mutants that could selectively replicate the distinct activities exhibited by either unmodified or oxidized Kar2. We found that the ATPase activity displayed by unmodified Kar2 is fully maintained when Cys63 is replaced with Ala or Val. Conversely, we demonstrate that several amino acid substitutions (including His, Phe, Pro, Trp, Tyr) support an enhanced viability during oxidative stress associated with oxidized Kar2, although these alleles are compromised as an ATPase. We reveal the range of activity demonstrated by wild-type Kar2 can be replicated by co-expression of Kar2 mutants that mimic either the unmodified or oxidized Kar2 state, allowing for growth during standard and oxidative stress conditions.