“…It is possible to suppress this roughness in a number of ways. Surfactants such as Sb and Bi are very efficient at reducing roughness [6,7,12,13], but each one increases the defect density (leading to lower device performance) and changes the carrier concentration (leading to low depletion widths and low photocurrents) [6,7,11]. It is also possible to get smooth morphologies by lowering the In content, but for 1.0 eV GaInNAs solar cells, this obviously produces strained material that has a good chance of forming extended defects during the growth of the 3-mm-thick base layer.…”