Black Representation in the Primary Care Physician Workforce and Its Association With Population Life Expectancy and Mortality Rates in the US

Abstract

ImportanceStudies have suggested that greater primary care physician (PCP) availability is associated with better population health and that a diverse health workforce can improve care experience measures. However, it is unclear whether greater Black representation within the PCP workforce is associated with improved health outcomes among Black individuals.ObjectiveTo assess county-level Black PCP workforce representation and its association with mortality-related outcomes in the US.Design, Setting, and ParticipantsThis cohort study evaluated the association of Black PCP workforce representation with survival outcomes at 3 time points (from January 1 to December 31 each in 2009, 2014, and 2019) for US counties. County-level representation was defined as the ratio of the proportion of PCPs who identifed as Black divided by the proportion of the population who identified as Black. Analyses focused on between- and within-county influences of Black PCP representation and treated Black PCP representation as a time-varying covariate. Analysis of between-county influences examined whether, on average, counties with increased Black representation exhibited improved survival outcomes. Analysis of within-county influences assessed whether counties with higher-than-usual Black PCP representation exhibited enhanced survival outcomes during a given year of heightened workforce diversity. Data analyses were performed on June 23, 2022.Main Outcomes and MeasuresUsing mixed-effects growth models, the impact of Black PCP representation on life expectancy and all-cause mortality for Black individuals and on mortality rate disparities between Black and White individuals was assessed.ResultsA combined sample of 1618 US counties was identified based on whether at least 1 Black PCP operated within a county during 1 or more time points (2009, 2014, and 2019). Black PCPs operated in 1198 counties in 2009, 1260 counties in 2014, and 1308 counties in 2019—less than half of all 3142 Census-defined US counties as of 2014. Between-county influence results indicated that greater Black workforce representation was associated with higher life expectancy and was inversely associated with all-cause Black mortality and mortality rate disparities between Black and White individuals. In adjusted mixed-effects growth models, a 10% increase in Black PCP representation was associated with a higher life expectancy of 30.61 days (95% CI, 19.13-42.44 days).Conclusions and RelevanceThe findings of this cohort study suggest that greater Black PCP workforce representation is associated with better population health measures for Black individuals, although there was a dearth of US counties with at least 1 Black PCP during each study time point. Investments to build a more representative PCP workforce nationally may be important for improving population health.

Perspectives About Racism and Patient-Clinician Communication Among Black Adults With Serious Illness

“…Supporting patients during conversations around medical decision-making with trusted clinicians, especially those who are race concordant, may help patients make decisions based on personal values and preferences unencumbered by concerns of bias . Indeed, improving workforce diversity is crucial to addressing these disparities given that race concordance for Black patients has been associated with improved health and health care outcomes, including mortality …”

The Supreme Court’s Rulings on Race Neutrality Threaten Progress in Medicine and Health

“…The rulings will have the most direct consequences for medical education. Black people living in counties with more Black primary care physicians have lower mortality rates (for every 10% increase in the share of Black primary care clinicians, there is a 30-day higher age-standardized life expectancy) . Yet there are very few Black physicians—another legacy of structural racism, implemented when the Flexner report of 1910 forced the closure of all but 2 Black medical schools.…”

“…During oral arguments, Justice Brett Kavanaugh began looking at the next question on the horizon: whether admissions officers may use race-neutral means such as disadvantage to promote racial diversity. Similarly, when the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld an elite high school’s decision to set aside seats for top students at middle schools in the county (favoring economically disadvantaged students), the dissenting justice decried the policy as having “an undisputed racial motivation and an undeniable racial result.” This case, or others, may rise to the Supreme Court, giving justices an opportunity to take action against indices that can function as a proxy for racism …”

The Supreme Court Decision on Affirmative Action—Fewer Black Physicians and More Health Disparities for Minoritized Groups

“…Although such policies helped achieve gender equality in medical school enrollment, the Court’s decision takes away an important tool for institutions of higher education seeking to achieve racial equity and increase the number of Black medical students. Health care practitioners from Black and other minority communities that continue to experience unconscionably disproportionate morbidity and mortality have been documented to have a key role in efforts to achieve optimal health for all US residents . Although we and others have launched a number of major research efforts for diseases such as diabetes, heart disease, and maternal mortality that impact minority communities, racial and ethnic minority groups continue to have these illnesses in higher percentages than White individuals …”