“…Although the conceptual strength of optogenetics and other cell “capture techniques” is the precise localization of the sparse network of neurons that make up an isolated engram (see Figure 1 ), the physical representation of a complex episodic engram is much more likely the emergent property of interactive memory systems (Tulving, 1987 ; Nyberg et al, 1998 ; McDonald et al, 2004a , b , 2017 ). Other technical problems of optogenetics may be considered, such as off-target effects in downstream circuits, as well as other spatial and temporal factors (Otchy et al, 2015 ; Südhof, 2015 ; Yates, 2016 ; Hardt and Nadel, 2017 ; McDonald and Deibel, 2017 ). For example, the specificity of a few neurons active in one area seems to mimic an in vitro -like isolation approach, while the snapshot-like association specificity in learning limits the unfolding of an event over time.…”