This paper and a subsequent one will present the results of an investigation which analytically relates the fiber/matrix nonlinearities to the postyielding behavior of symmetric laminates made from unidirectional plies. This first paper is primarily concerned with the behavior of the single ply and the means for anticipating its response within a laminate. Boron and carbon/epoxies are considered along with a metal matrix composite. The qualitative features of the response of these unidirectional materials to normal, shear, and combined loads are discussed. The analysis (based on triangular finite element idealizations of regularly-spaced inclusion arrays) anticipates the level of nonlinearity that has been observed in composite shear and transverse tensile tests. Also, it reveals a nonlinear coupling that may exist between the combined shear and normal stress response.