Breaking Resilient Patterns of Inequality in Santiago de Chile: Challenges to Navigate towards a More Sustainable City

Abstract

Abstract:Resilience can have desirable and undesirable consequences. Thus, resilience should not be viewed as a normative desirable goal, but as a descriptor of complex systems dynamics. From this perspective, we apply resilience thinking concepts to assess the dynamics of inequality, spatial segregation, and sustainability in Chile's capital city of Santiago. Chile's economy boosted since democracy was restored in 1990, but continuity of neoliberal reforms and transformations of Pinochet's dictatorship (1973)(1974)(1975)(1976)(1977)(1978)(1979)(1980)(1981)(1982)(1983)(1984)(1985)(1986)(1987)(1988)(1989)(1990) seem to have locked Chilean cities in resilient, albeit unsustainable, patterns of uneven development. Socio-economic data from Santiago shows highly resilient patterns of urban inequality and segregation from 1992 to 2009 despite democratic efforts, political agendas and discourses packed with calls for reducing poverty and inequality. We present a conceptual model based on the notion of stability landscapes to explore potential trade-offs between resilience and sustainable development. We mapped Santiago's spatio-temporal inequality trends and explored if these patterns support an inequality-resilience stability landscape. Analysis of temporal and spatial distribution of development assets across four human development dimensions (i.e., income, education, health, democracy) revealed potential socio-political and spatial feedbacks supporting the resilience of inequality and segregation in Santiago. We argue that urban sustainability may require breaking this resilience, a process where bottom-up stressors such as social movements could play a key role.

Social Capital, Race, and Income Inequality in the United States

“…Using this SCI, Putnam argued that social capital had a profound effect on how American states performed in terms of economic prosperity, health and happiness, democracy, criminal justice and public education, among others. An equally resilient system in public education and health is necessary to decrease income inequality and to sustain economic development [10,11]. While Putnam's seminal work on social capital has drawn attention from both scholarly communities as well as popular media outlets, his SCI has not produced a uniform level of support among scholars.…”

Reconstructing Powerful Knowledge in an era of climate change

“…Just as inequality can be sustainable, so communities living in poverty can be resilient. We must be wary of promoting resilience in the context of austerity politics which withdraw municipal support from neighborhoods because they are 'resilient' (Fernández, Manuel-Navarrete and Torres-Salinas, 2016).…”

Good Urban Governance and City Resilience: An Afrocentric Approach to Sustainable Development

“…Sustainable urban development is high on Africa's development agenda because the rate of urbanization has almost doubled since the early 1990s [8]. However, pervasive poverty, inequalities, climate change, and poor urban spatial planning have hampered cities' ability to become more resilient [24].…”