Tuberculous mastitis (TM) is a rare form of tuberculosis, occurring as a primary disease when there is no evidence of tuberculosis in other locations. There are no clear clinical features of TM, especially in the absence of a previous tuberculosis infection. Due to its unclear clinical picture, diagnosis is difficult, and it is often confused with breast carcinoma or pyogenic abscesses. The aim of this study was to report our experience and discuss the characteristics and diagnostic modalities in cases of primary TM in a tuberculosis-endemic area. Method A case series study was conducted at the Arifin Achmad Regional Hospital, reporting four cases of primary tuberculous mastitis in January 2024. The patients were women aged 24-41 years. Case presentation All patients presented with complaints of breast pain for the last 2 weeks to 2 months and complained of symptoms in the form of a lump in the breast that was reddish in colour and mastalgia. One patient was diagnosed during pregnancy, and one had a history of prior breastfeeding. One patient presented with FNAB results for breast carcinoma. The other patient complained of an ulcer on her breast. Physical examination revealed axillary lymphadenopathy in all patients. Histopathological examination revealed tuberculous mastitis in all patients and 1 with tuberculous mastitis, fibrocystic changes, and Atypical Ductal Hyperplasia (ADH). Conclusion Patients with tuberculous mastitis who visited our institution had symptoms similar to those of abscesses and breast cancer. The FNAC test is the most reliable, but false-negative results can occur. Diagnosis requires teamwork between the patient’s doctor, anatomical pathologist, and radiologist. This research requires a larger scale to describe actual conditions.