Breastfeeding Among Mothers Who Have Experienced Childhood Maltreatment: A Review

Abstract

Background Current breastfeeding recommendations focus on the physical benefits of breastfeeding but do not take into account the influence of a history of childhood maltreatment on mothers’ experiences breastfeeding. A better understanding of this relationship is important to be able to better support mothers during this critical time. Research aim To review current research that examined how women’s personal experiences of childhood maltreatment has affected their breastfeeding outcomes and experiences. Methods A scoping review was conducted to evaluate current literature on breastfeeding and childhood maltreatment. We screened 275 articles, of which eight met the sample selection criteria and were included in this review. These articles were analyzed based on common themes that emerged: Breastfeeding intention, initiation, duration, and exclusivity; medical conditions associated with breastfeeding; and participants’ experiences related to breastfeeding. Results History of childhood maltreatment was associated with decreased and shorter duration of breastfeeding. Participants’ experiences of breastfeeding varied: Some found it empowering, and others experienced great distress while breastfeeding. Challenges during this period included managing touch, struggling with the power differential between providers and participants, and coping with trauma symptoms (e.g., dissociation). Conclusions For some participants, it was possible to breastfeed successfully after childhood maltreatment, but others found the experience extremely difficult, even traumatizing. There is a need for a trauma-informed approach to lactation care for women with a childhood maltreatment history.

Violence and adversity among pregnant women and new mothers in central Vietnam

“…In contrast, some studies concluded that when questions about subjective wellbeing and perceived stress were combined with depression scores, more mothers with common health problems (Smithson et al, 2020;Xu et al, 2017), or behaviour problem (e.g. failure of exclusive breastfeeding) (Channell-Doig et al, 2020;Young et al, 2020) were identified. This brief combination of questions about positive wellbeing, stress and depression may help to enhance focus on women's well-being during primary care (Accortt & Wong, 2017;Melville & Hincks, 2016;O'Connor et al, 2016;Thombs et al, 2018)…”

A balancing act—midwives' and public health nurses' experiences with breastfeeding counselling

“…Listening can help healthcare professionals understand if such abuse is the cause of their breastfeeding problems. According to Sørbø et al [47] and Chanell Doig et al [48], past and recent abuse of women can be associated with early cessation of breastfeeding and, thus, healthcare professionals must be aware of women who are experiencing these problems and provide support and care that allows them to find breastfeeding empowering and healing. According to Martinsen [19], care can be shown through practical work and, according to our findings, breastfeeding counselling that is characterised by trust, acceptance and engagement with the situation can give healthcare workers opportunities to provide appropriate care that can contribute to relieving families' challenges.…”

Associations Between Mothers’ Adverse Childhood Experiences, Material Hardship, and Breastfeeding Challenges in the United States

“…It is important to note that research in this area is mixed. Channell Doig and colleagues (2020) reported that experiences of childhood abuse were associated with decreased and earlier cessation of breastfeeding and, while Watson and colleagues (2021) determined that living with someone who was incarcerated was one specific ACE associated with early breastfeeding cessation, this did not hold true for the other ACEs examined. Furthermore, researchers found increased breastfeeding initiation among study participants with more ACEs (Watson et al, 2021), suggesting that trauma survivors may have the same or even greater intention to breastfeed despite obstacles.…”