Brief Therapy in Adult Psychiatry – Further Outcomes

Abstract

A report of a one-year follow-up of thirty-six referrals treated with solutionfocused brief therapy by a supervised team in a mental health setting is described. A good outcome was reported for twenty-three cases (64%). These results are comparable with our previous work and with one other statistically validated outcome study on solution-focused therapy. IntroductionAs financial stringency begins to affect healthcare in all countries, there is an increasing need for outcome studies in order to guide the work of individual practitioners and to allow rational decisions about expenditure on services. Our team has practised solutionfocused brief therapy in the context of adult mental health for six years. In a previous study of our first three years' work (Macdonald, 1994), we reported a good outcome for 70% of our referrals and we now report results from a further cohort of referrals seen over a subsequent three-year period. Therapeutic approachWe work as a multi-disciplinary team using live supervision for both trainees and experienced therapists. We serve a scattered rural population and usually see attenders once a month. Our referrals come from general practitioners and colleagues in the mental health services. The team does not act as the first point of contact for those with an acute psychosis but all other referrals are seen at least once. The problems presented by our attenders are similar to those seen at local psychiatric outpatient clinics.A letter is sent to all referrals describing the team approach and a Consultant Psychiatrist/Psychotherapist, Garlands Hospital, Carlisle CA1 3SX, UK. notifying them of their rights in relation to videotaping. This follows the suggestions of Birch (1990) about the value of presession contacts and consent procedures in setting a context for therapy. The letter invites clients to contact us for an appointment and suggests that they will have started making changes before they see us. We send a written copy of the closing intervention to the attenders after each session which reinforces our comments during the interval between meetings and is generally appreciated by attenders.We use a solution-focused brief therapy model (de Shazer, 1994;Macdonald, 1994). Sessions revolve around goals chosen by the attenders. Exceptions to the existing problem are emphasized in discussion, and scaling of problems from 1-10 is used to provide a neutral way of assessing change and to assist discussion about small steps on the way to the goal. The 'miracle question': 'What if a miracle happens and the problem is solved?' is used to develop a picture of a new and better future towards which attenders can move. Follow-up designAs in our 1994 study, we sent follow-up questionnaires by post to attenders and their general practitioners one year after their last session (see Appendix). The questions were derived from Watzlawick et al. (1974) andde Shazer (1985) and sought information about the problem, goal achievement, any new problems and any further advice sought from other professionals. Com...

The Development of the Solution Building Inventory

“…Several clinicians outside of the original group of SFBT developers have also done follow-up studies on SFBT (Lee, 1997;Macdonald, 1997;Morrison, Olivos, Dominguez, Gomez, & Lena, 1993;Schorr, 1997). In addition, Schorr used a pre-post test design using the State-Trait…”

Factors related to the length of solution-focused brief therapy working with adolescents

“…Vertinant rigidiškumo įtaką konsultacijų dažnu-mui, galima prielaida, kad labiau rigidiškiems paaugliams dėl jiems būdingo mažesnio socialumo ir bendravimo sunkumų (23) gali būti sunkiau suprasti būtiny-bę keisti savo elgseną, todėl, siekiant teigiamų pokyčių, šiems paaugliams reikia daugiau laiko ir pagalbos. Tai, kad paaugliams, kurie konsultacijų metu sprendžia-mą problemą vertino kaip lengvesnę, reikėjo mažiau konsultacijų sprendimams rasti, atitinka kitų autorių pastebėjimus, kad geresnių konsultacijos rezultatų pasiekiama, kai sprendžiamos problemos lengvesnės (24).…”

Solution‐Focused Brief Therapy: A Review of the Outcome Research*

“…Several clinician‐researchers outside the Milwaukee group have also conducted followup studies of SFBT (Lee, 1997; Macdonald, 1997; Morrison, Olivos, Dominguez, et al, 1993; Schorr, 1997). For the most part, these studies also used subjective outcome measures and found similar but somewhat smaller success rates.…”