Briefing: Burkina Faso's reversal on genetically modified cotton and the implications for Africa

Abstract

CAN GENETICALLY MODIFIED (GM) CROPS help smallholder farmers in sub-Saharan Africa? To date, only two GM cropsinsect-resistant forms of cotton and maizehave made it into the hands of African farmers. Of these, GM cotton has the longest empirical track record, having been the first GM crop ever introduced in Africa, and the only one that has been grown in multiple countries-first South Africa, then Burkina Faso. 1 The performance of this crop has received intense scrutiny, as it offers the best indication of how the suite of other GM crops slated for commercial approval may perform across the continent. This briefing reviews the experiences of South African farmers with GM cotton, which has emerged as the crucial precedent highlighting the value of GM crops for poor farmers. It then turns to the case of Burkina Faso, which became the showcase for how GM crops can benefit smallholder African farmers. However, as shown here, Burkina Faso has begun a complete phaseout of GM cotton, citing the inferior lint quality of the GM cultivars as the reason for abandoning its cultivation. Burkina Faso's phase-out could stall or even end negotiations to adopt GM cotton in other Francophone African countries with similar concerns over cotton quality. More generally, Burkina Faso's reversal could undermine public trust in GM crops across the continent at a time when many African countries are grappling with the politicized and polarized debate over whether to adopt these new breeding technologies. We argue that the retreat of Burkina Faso, one of the most prominent and

Peasant essentialism in GMO debates: Bt cotton in Burkina Faso

“…1 Bt cotton was first grown in Burkina Faso in field trials in 2003, commercialized in 2008 with select farmers for seed production, and then on a wider basis in 2009 (Compaoré Sawadogo, 2018;Dowd-Uribe & Schnurr, 2016). 2 Monsanto's Bollgard II cotton produced the proteins Cry1Ac and Cry2Ab (from the soil bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis), which kill Lepidopteran larvae (common cotton pests; Dowd-Uribe & Bingen, 2011).…”

Le Coton Biotechnologique au Burkina Faso : Trajectoire d’une Innovation dans un Contexte de Développement

“…Dans un processus d'innovation c'est un point crucial pour la pérennisation de l'innovation. Au début de 2016 au bout de sept ans de commercialisation le coton Bt a été officiellement abandonné en raison du manque à gagner en quantité de fibres produites, de la réduction de la longueur de la fibre (DOWD-URIBE et SCHNURR, 2016, FOK 2016.…”

The Release of Genetically Engineered Mosquitoes in Burkina Faso: Bioeconomy of Science, Public Engagement and Trust in Medicine

“…Monsanto partnered with the Burkinabè government in 2003 and started to introduce Bt cotton to farmers from 2008. In the years that followed, Bt cotton proved to be increasingly popular, and by 2013 Monsanto’s Bt cotton market share rose to 70 percent (Dowd-Uribe & Schnurr 2016). However, the quality of Bt cotton gradually worsened in comparison to the renowned quality of conventional cotton in Burkina Faso.…”