Bringing design practices to chemistry classrooms: studying teachers’ pedagogical ideas in the context of a professional learning community

Abstract

Bringing design practices to chemistry education is gaining interest with recent science curriculum reforms emphasising design, and calls for integrated STEM education. Design is a central practice in the chemistry discipline, and could foster meaningful chemistry education. Although chemistry teachers are key in bringing design to chemistry classrooms, and in realising design's potential for learning, little is known about their views on teaching and learning regarding design. To reduce this gap in literature, we explored chemistry teachers' pedagogical ideas in the context of a Dutch professional learning community on design in chemistry education. We elicited teachers' ideas through semi-structured interviews and lesson forms which teachers kept while implementing a design project. Multiple patterns emerged through analysing teachers' ideas. We found that the teachers did not see teaching design as a goal of chemistry education. Instead, teachers valued design as a teaching approach to engage students in applying chemistry concepts, in developing soft skills, and in applying or developing research practices. In this paper, we present more patterns in teachers' ideas, and discuss possible explanations of these findings in depth. Finally, we give suggestions for future research, and teacher professional development that may help support a change to bring design into chemistry education.

Modeling Chinese Teachers’ Efficacies for the Teaching of Integrated STEM With Interdisciplinary Communication and Epistemic Fluency

“…In response to these challenges and barriers, it is necessary to engage teachers in epistemic activities to co-design with other professionals to create needed knowledge ( Shernoff et al, 2017 ; Wu et al, 2019 ; Stammes et al, 2020 ). The interplay among the disciplines is complex and requires teachers to deliver the learning content purposefully and deliberately so that students can transfer their knowledge and skills in new or authentic contexts ( Moore et al, 2014 ; Kelley and Knowles, 2016 ).…”

Indonesian Science, Mathematics, and Engineering Preservice Teachers’ Experiences in STEM-TPACK Design-Based Learning

“…Thus, ISTEM education faces multiple barriers, including time, interdisciplinary communication, teaching materials, and alignment to the curriculum standards [9]. For teachers to develop the capacities to facilitate ISTEM learning, it has been advocated that they should acquire substantial co-design experience involving diverse expertise in professional learning community to create the knowledge needed [15,16]. This study draws on the existing literature of the technological pedagogical content knowledge (TPACK) [17] and the notion of Webquest [18] to create a preservice teacher professional development (TPD) course to enhance their TPACK for STEM education.…”

Teachers Noticing Chemical Thinking While Students Plan and Draw Designs

“…And, with students' realisation that they were "supposed to" design a product with separate containers for reactants, and a mechanism for bringing these together ("that's the critical point of the design which actually always goes wrong"). This could be another example of what we had found in an earlier study, namely that these teachers had a different focus in their goals for designing in chemistry education (Stammes, Henze, Barendsen, & de Vries, 2020). A teacher's noticing in classroom contexts is additionally impacted by factors such as the extent to which students disclose their thinking, either voluntarily or prompted (Cowie and Bell, 1999).…”