“…(14), there exist three points, i.e., 0, 1, and 1−0:5 1 2 m −1 , where p 1 (n + 1) is equal to p 1 (n) for each shape parameter m. According to the renormalization group theory, 0 and 1 are stable fixed points, which represent completely stable and completely unstable states, respectively, while the critical point p à ¼ 1−0:5 1 2 m −1 is an unstable fixed point, i.e., a phase transition point, where the state changes from stable to unstable ( Figure 6). As suggested by Qin et al (2010b) and Xue et al (2014b), it is thought that the critical point p ⁎ corresponds to the concept of the critical probability as mentioned in Section 3.1. Thus, we have demonstrated the inherent essence of the onset of tertiary creep (point C) from a mathematical point of view.…”