Core Message• Discovery of genetically distinct hantaviruses in multiple species of shrews and moles (order Eulipotyphla) and insectivorous bats (order Chiroptera) heralds a new frontier in hantavirology.• Acquisition of new knowledge about the spatial and temporal distribution, host range and genetic diversity of newfound hantaviruses harbored by shrews, moles, and bats was accelerated by having access to archival tissue collections.• Newfound hantaviruses in shrews, moles, and bats are genetically more diverse than those hosted by rodents (order Rodentia), suggesting that the evolutionary origins of hantaviruses are more ancient and complex than previously contemplated. • Phylogenetic analyses indicate four distinct hantavirus clades, with evidence of both co-divergence and host switching, and suggest that shrews, moles, and/or bats may have predated rodents as the early reservoir hosts of primordial hantaviruses.• Detection of hantavirus RNA in ethanol-fi xed tissues greatly expands the pool of specimens for future hantavirus-discovery efforts, particularly in other insectivorous small mammals, such as hedgehogs and tenrecs.• The lack of cell culture isolates of the newly detected hantaviruses hosted by shrews, moles, and bats has hampered the identifi cation and investigation of novel hantaviral diseases.