Lipoleiomyoma is a type of tumor usually found in the uterine corpus. The pathophysiology is unclear; however, it is commonly seen in obese perimenopausal and postmenopausal women. While intrauterine lipoleiomyoma may be surveilled, there is less information about the management of extrauterine lipoleiomyoma, especially significantly large tumors. This is a case involving a 51-year-old female who was incidentally found to have a 23-cm extrauterine lipoleiomyoma emanating from the peritoneum between uterosacral ligaments. She underwent handassisted laparoscopic removal of an intra-abdominal tumor, which was found to be an extrauterine lipoleiomyoma. Six months later, she was found to have a recurrent mass on a follow-up computed tomography (CT) of the abdomen and pelvis. She underwent a robotic-assisted total abdominal hysterectomy, bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy, and removal of the recurrent tumor.While the mass is benign in nature, the mass effect that it may cause prompts a discussion about the best course of management and an investigation into recurrence rates, specifically in similar extrauterine presentations.