Scarce availability of chemical starting materials is a crucial challenge in the development of flow chemical processes. This is particularly important for organometallic reactions, which typically require high flow rates and hence high material consumption, to generate sufficiently short mixing and residence times. To address this issue, micromixers that mix efficiently even at small Re numbers and that have a low tendency of clogging are necessary. Here, we propose the usage of microannular gear pumps as active mixers, which allow the reduction of material consumption by >10-fold while achieving fast mixing times for common organometallic reactions. This novel approach is benchmarked against several commercially available mixers with respect to the mixing time at low flow rates, showing that the gear pumps can achieve fast mixing (< 50 ms) even at <1 mL/min. To assess the crucially important factor of time to blockage in a consistent manner, a novel protocol is developed based on the controlled precipitation of lithium salts during the mixing process. This shows that the gear pump is significantly more robust than common mixers as operation can be maintained for over 2 h. Lastly, we highlight that the microannular gear pump approach allows the manipulation of mixing time at equal residence time, by tuning the rotation speed, thus allowing for characterization of the mixing sensitivity of reactions. Taken together, our multiparametric analysis of common mixing approaches highlights that the usage of microannular gear pumps for active mixing of fast organometallic reactions presents a powerful alternative able to address current limitations of organic process development.