Building a high‐resolution chronology of a medieval urban site through Bayesian modelling*

Haase, Kirstine; Olsen, Jesper

doi:10.1111/arcm.12651

Cited by 4 publications

(4 citation statements)

References 22 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…Behind the booths, the plots were still occupied by scattered buildings, stables, wells, workshops and pits. Furthermore, brick was introduced as a building material, resulting in the construction of a two-storey brick house, 7 m south of the street (Haase 2017, 119;Haase and Olsen 2021). The finds from this period are similar to those of 1000 to 1150.…”

Section: Finds From the Settlementmentioning

confidence: 95%

“…Several houses were built around 1000 to 1150, and to the north, a broad, paved market street was established as part of the overall street layout. Radiocarbon dates and dendrochronological analysis suggest that the street was used between the late 11 th century and the early 12 th century (Haase and Olsen 2021;Runge and Henriksen 2018, 46). The street debris reveal remains of leatherwork, non-ferrous metalwork (crucible fragments, copper alloys and lead) and bone/antler work (Haase 2017, 99;132;Jouttijärvi 2015).…”

Section: Finds From the Settlementmentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

When God came to Town - Urban Development and Religious Practices in early medieval Odense, Denmark

Haase

Bjerregaard²

2022

DJA

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

This article presents a contextual approach to studying the role of the urban environment in introducing Christianity to Denmark between 900 and 1250. We consider sensory experience and apply the concept of lived religion to the highly varied and sometimes limited archaeological material from St Alban’s church in Odense, its cemetery, and the surrounding settlement, to show that the urban environment played an active role in integrating Christianity into everyday life. The church and king used the urban environment to stage their authority. The message of Christianity was propagated through religious practices, such as celebrating Saint Cnut with spectacular processions, and dress accessories with religious motifs. These practices facilitated the transformation from an elite-oriented missionary religion promoted by the king and the elite to a widely accepted religion integrated into the everyday lives of Odense’s inhabitants.

show abstract

Section: Finds From the Settlementmentioning

confidence: 95%

Section: Finds From the Settlementmentioning

confidence: 99%

When God came to Town - Urban Development and Religious Practices in early medieval Odense, Denmark

Haase

Bjerregaard²

2022

DJA

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…The merchant house had a semi-basement that was accessible from the street. Unfortunately for the inhabitants, the house burned down between ad 1407 and 1438 (Haase and Olsen 2021). The ceramics left in the rubble showed a large amount of drinking-related tableware such as jugs and bowls, suggesting that the basement also served as an inn (Fig.…”

Section: Adding New Work In Urban Animal Husbandrymentioning

confidence: 99%

Animal Husbandry, Import Replacement, and Urban Growth in Medieval Odense, Denmark

Haase¹

2022

Journal of Urban Archaeology

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Issuing from Jane Jacobs's concepts of 'import replacement' and 'adding new work to old', this paper proposes that these processes can be traced in the archaeo logical record of the early stages of the medi eval city Odense in Denmark. It is suggested that Jacobs's concepts help model the drivers of urban growth and expansion of economy. Therefore, it is suggested that Jacobs's concepts are an alternative way of studying and comparing settlements regardless of their functional, topo graphical, or administrative traits. The paper also proposes that social processes of interdependency, related to co-presence and the dynamics of growth, are defining for the urban way of life. The argument is developed through an analysis of use and strategies towards animal resources -meat, bones, fur, and leather.

show abstract

“…Derfor blev kombinationen af de stratigraske oplysninger, C14-dateringerne og de dendrokonologiske dateringer afgørende for etableringen af en absolut kronologi for udgravningen. 37 Det er dog ikke den overordnede kronologiske model, der er i centrum i dette eksempel. I stedet vil vi dykke ned i en konkret sekvens relateret til en af udgravningens kaeldre og vise, hvordan en kombination af C14-dateringerne relateret til kaelderen, de stratigraske informationer og de dendrokronologiske dateringer af en stratigrask aeldre latrin i en kronologisk model kan gøre C14-dateringerne til et vaerdifuldt redskab i arbejdet med urban middelalderarkaeologi.…”

Section: En Middelalderkaelder I Odense -Et Eksempel På Kombination A...unclassified

Bayesiansk kronologisk modellering som redskab i den lovpligtige arkæologi

Villumsen,

Haase,

Torfing

et al. 2022

Kuml

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Bayesian chronological modelling in Danish archaeologyIn Danish archaeology, radiocarbon dating has become an integrated part of the archaeological toolbox. A certain scepticism towards the accuracy of the method means, however, that it often remains a supplement to archaeological interpretation and other informal dating methods.Bayesian modelling counters this scepticism by combining radiocarbon dating with archaeological observations and other dating methods such as stratigraphy, dendrochronology and numismatic dating. Based on data from sources such as these, a Bayesian model calculates the statistical probability distribution of individual radiocarbon dates. Because the modelled dates consider all available information relating to the samples and their context, they can produce more accurate, robust dates and chronologies than those based on simple calibrated dates. Moreover, through Bayesian modelling, it is possible to estimate the dates of events that cannot be dated directly, such as the beginning or end of a settlement phase.The benefits of implementing Bayesian modelling in Danish archaeology are considerable. However, given that it can seem confusing and difficult to comprehend, in the following we will introduce the method by presenting and discussing some examples of Bayesian modelling.Radiocarbon dates are probabilistic, which means that each radiocarbon measurement holds considerable uncertainty. Each radiocarbon date is expressed as a bell-shaped normal distribution around a median (fig. 1). The date is reported as a radiocarbon age and a standard deviation (e.g. 1690 BP ± 30 years). The uncertainty of the radiocarbon measurement is often increased through calibration to calendar years by matching with the wiggles and plateaus of the calibration curve. Since calibrated radiocarbon dates are distributed around the radiocarbon sample’s actual age, a visual assessment of the calibration plot will often lead to misinterpretation of the date of specific events or the beginning, end, or duration of phases. Bayesian statistics is a way of countering these uncertainties and misinterpretations. In the following, we use the calibration program OxCal. The first example is a fictional case where ten simulated radiocarbon dates, corresponding to known years at 10-year intervals between AD 970 and 1060, are calibrated (fig. 2). From a visual assessment of the calibrated dates, it seems they are contemporaneous since the probability distribution of each individual date is up to 200 years. The wide probability distribution blurs the fact that the events are each ten years apart. If we add the prior information that the events form a sequence in which sample A is older than sample B etc., the modelled dates then display narrower probability distributions (fig. 3). These are called posterior probability distributions. A so-called Boundary is added to the model to limit the sequence and mark the first and last non-dated event, since it is unlikely that a sample representing the first and last event in a sequence has been taken.Stratigraphic information is termed an informative prior, while an uninformative prior represents a situation where the only information about the samples is that they belong to the same phase. Uninformative priors are illustrated by five samples from the postholes of an Iron Age house. The house had been in use for 30 years. The simulated dates are then placed within a 30-year period (fig. 4). Again, the unmodelled dates blur the actual duration of the use-phase of the house. The prior information that the samples are interpreted as being contemporaneous is now added to the model using the Phase command. The model then estimates when the use of the house began and when it ended. In OxCal, the Agreement Index, A, is an indicator of the match between the data and the model. It is based on the overlap of the calibrated probability distribution and the posterior distributions. An Agreement Index below 60% is an indication of a problematic sample. An Agreement Index is also calculated for the whole model (Amodel).In a more complex example, stratigraphical information regarding the Iron Age house is added. Samples from a stratigraphically younger house and a younger pit are added to the model as two phases in a sequence (fig. 5). The three samples from the pit are regarded as being contemporaneous, and the ‘combine’ command is used.In the simulated example, five samples are enough to create a robust model for a house’s use-phase. But the number of samples needed also depends on where on the calibration curve the dates end up, and a small number of samples may be compensated for by strong priors. The following example is not simulated but from the excavation of an Iron Age house. Three samples were taken from a roof-bearing post. The samples were taken from growth rings spaced, respectively, 10 and 12 years apart. The charred remains of hazel wattle were found between the stones in the cobbled floor (fig. 6). The hazel was interpreted as the remains of the wattle walls of the excavated house. Two ditches surrounding the house were sampled, one of which was stratigraphically older than the other. The samples and the prior information were combined in a Bayesian model. The house’s date was narrowed from 158-8 BC to 91-6 BC (fig. 7).The final example is from the excavation of a medieval house in a town (fig. 10). Five samples from the floors in the house’s basement were added in a Bayesian model (fig. 9). The floors superseded each other. Moreover, two dendrochronological samples from latrine barrels, older than the house, and samples from the barrels’ content were added to the model (fig. 10). Based on the archaeological interpretation, the use of the house was dated to between AD 1250 and 1450. However, the model showed that it was more likely to have been in use between AD 1413 and 1487 (fig. 11). This new date suggests that the potsherds found in the floor layers were redeposited. These examples demonstrate the considerable potential of Bayesian modelling. However, they also show that it is essential to exercise great care in constructing the model and providing a thorough account of the archaeological priors. It may be necessary to create several models to test the priors’ robustness or to test different priors. Bayesian modelling presents a systematic and formalised way to test various archaeological interpretations.

show abstract

Building a high‐resolution chronology of a medieval urban site through Bayesian modelling*

Cited by 4 publications

References 22 publications

When God came to Town - Urban Development and Religious Practices in early medieval Odense, Denmark

When God came to Town - Urban Development and Religious Practices in early medieval Odense, Denmark

Animal Husbandry, Import Replacement, and Urban Growth in Medieval Odense, Denmark

Bayesiansk kronologisk modellering som redskab i den lovpligtige arkæologi

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About