Building Long Term Trust in Vehicular Networks

Peer Review #1 of "State-of-the-art IoV trust management a meta-synthesis systematic literature review (SLR) (v0.2)"

“…Manuscript to be reviewed Manuscript to be reviewed (Ahmad et al 2018) 2018 Hybrid J (Gazdar et al 2018) 2018 Entity J (Soleymani et al 2017) 2017 Entity J (Ahmed et al 2017) 2017 Hybrid J (Biswas et al 2016) 2016 Hybrid C (Hussain et al 2016) 2016 Hybrid C (Sedjelmaci & Senouci 2015) 2015 Hybrid J (Haddadou et al 2015) 2015 Entity J (Rawat et al 2015) 2015 Data J (Ya et al 2015) 2015 Entity J (Rostamzadeh et al 2015) 2015 Hybrid J (Alagar & Wan 2015) 2015 Entity C (Abdelaziz et al 2014) 2014 Entity C (Wahab et al 2014) 2014 Hybrid J (Shaikh & Alzahrani 2014) 2014 Data J (Wei et al 2014) 2014 Hybrid C (Yang 2013) 2013 hybrid J (Chen & Wei 2013) 2013 Hybrid J (Li et al 2013) 2013 Hybrid C (Zhang et al 2013) 2013 Hybrid J (Monir et al 2013) 2013 Entity C (Rehman et al 2013) 2013 Data C (Li et al 2012) 2012 Entity J (Gazdar et al 2012) 2012 Hybrid C (Sahoo et al 2012) 2012 Entity J (Mármol & Pérez 2012) 2012 Entity J (Minhas et al 2011) 2011 Entity J (Biswas et al 2011) 2011 Entity C (Wu et al 2011) 2011 Data C (Chen et al 2010) 2010 Data C (Raya et al 2008) 2008 Data C 1 PeerJ Comput. Sci.…”

“…The presence of legitimate events and nodes in the system is an assumption. In a long-term trust relationship model (Biswas et al 2016) the main trust evaluation body is the RSU supported by CA at the top. The model assumes that all the vehicles in the networks are registered with the CA and maintain a certain level of trust.…”

“…In the early phases of VANET research, RSUs became an essential part of the VANET architecture (Behravesh & Butler 2016). Models (Alagar & Wan 2015;Biswas et al 2011;Biswas et al 2016;Li et al 2013;Monir et al 2013;Sedjelmaci & Senouci 2015;Wu et al 2011) that used the RSU as the main authority for TM were proposed. A "trust value" was assigned to an RSU depending on its location and coverage (Biswas et al 2016).…”

Peer Review #1 of "State-of-the-art IoV trust management a meta-synthesis systematic literature review (SLR) (v0.1)"

“…Manuscript to be reviewed (Ahmad et al 2018) yes (for role based) no 0.5 initial value no (Gazdar et al 2018) no no no no (Soleymani et al 2017 Manuscript to be reviewed Computer Science (Li et al 2012) no yes no no (Gazdar et al 2012) no no no no (Sahoo et al 2012) no no All new vehicles are trusted no (Mármol & Pérez 2012) yes no no no (Minhas et al 2011) no no no no (Biswas et al 2011) no Local public key no no (Wu et al 2011) no no no no (Chen et al 2010) no no no no (Raya et al 2008 Manuscript to be reviewed (Ahmad et al 2018) VEINS, SUMO, OMNET++ (Gazdar et al 2018) not discussed (Soleymani et al 2017) NS2, SUMO (Ahmed et al 2017) OMNET++ discrete event, network simulator (Biswas et al 2016) not discussed (Hussain et al 2016) not discussed (Sedjelmaci & Senouci 2015) NS-3 (Haddadou et al 2015) NS-2, SUMO (Rawat et al 2015) not discussed (Ya et al 2015) not discussed (Rostamzadeh et al 2015) MATLAB (Alagar & Wan 2015) not discussed (Abdelaziz et al 2014) NS-2 (Wahab et al 2014) MATLAB, network simulator, MobiSim traffic (Shaikh & Alzahrani 2014) SWANS++ (Wei et al 2014) not discussed (Yang 2013) not discussed (Chen & Wei 2013) not discussed (Li et al 2013) NA (Zhang et al 2013) not discussed (Monir et al 2013) MATLAB (Rehman et al 2013) not discussed (Li e...…”

“…Three subcategories of trust: events, nodes, and recommendations. (Biswas et al 2016) RSU add and manage trust. Long term trust relationship is maintained.…”