Despite the unique reactivity of vitamin B12 and its derivatives, B12‐dependent enzymes remain underutilized in biocatalysis. In this study, we repurpose the B12‐dependent transcription factor CarH to enable non‐native radical cyclization reactions. An engineered variant of this enzyme, CarH*, catalyzes the formation γ‐ and δ‐lactams via either redox‐neutral or reductive ring closure with marked enhancement of reactivity and selectivity relative to the free B12 cofactor. CarH* also catalyzes an unusual spirocyclization via dearomatization of pendant arenes to produce bicyclic 1,3‐diene products instead of 1,4‐dienes provided by existing methods. These results and associated mechanistic studies highlight the importance of protein scaffolds for controlling the reactivity of B12 and expanding the synthetic utility of B12‐dependent enzymes.