In the spirit of
the mounting interest in noncovalent interactions,
the present study was conducted to scrutinize a special type that
simultaneously involved both σ-hole and lone pair (lp) interactions
with aromatic π-systems. Square-pyramidal pentavalent halogen-containing
molecules, including X-Cl-F4, F-Y-F4, and F-I-X4 compounds (where X = F, Cl, Br, and I and Y = Cl, Br, and
I) were employed as σ-hole/lp donors. On the other hand, benzene
(BZN) and hexafluorobenzene (HFB) were chosen as electron-rich and
electron-deficient aromatic π-systems, respectively. The investigation
relied upon a variety of quantum chemical calculations that complement
each other. The results showed that (i) the binding energy of the
X-Y-F4···BZN complexes increased (i.e.,
more negative) as the Y atom had a larger magnitude of σ-hole,
contrary to the pattern of X-Y-F4···HFB
complexes; (ii) the interaction energies of X-Y-F4···BZN
complexes were dominated by both dispersion and electrostatic contributions,
while dispersive interactions dominated X-Y-F4···HFB
complexes; and (iii) the X4 atoms in F-I-X4···π-system
complexes governed the interaction energy pattern: the larger the
X4 atoms were, the greater the interaction energies were,
for the same π-system. The results had illuminating facets in
regard to the rarely addressed cases of the σ-hole/lp contradictory
scene.