“…We used multiple stimuli in the predator class and in the nonpredator class (control + novel) to avoid pseudoreplication (Johnson & Freeberg, 2016). Chickadees respond to novel stimuli in aviary contexts in ways intermediate to the birds’ responses to control and predator stimuli (Browning, 2015). These predator stimuli had been used in previous studies with chickadees and tufted titmice, Baeolophus bicolor , and were known to be effective stimuli at eliciting antipredator behavior (Bartmess-LeVasseur, Branch, Browning, Owens, & Freeberg, 2010; Zachau & Freeberg, 2012; Book & Freeberg, 2015; Freeberg, Book, & Weiner, 2016; Cantwell, Johnson, Kaschel, Love, & Freeberg, 2016).…”