“…For Nietzsche, the majority of citizens in contemporary democracies are implicitly indoctrinated into subconscious resentment, and as such will never know the power gratitude has to elevate their self-conceptions. Nevertheless, while Nietzsche himself is pessimistic about the prospects of educating democratic citizens out of their ressentiment, 3 he offers an image of gratitude that belies that 2 References for all of Nietzsche's texts will be abbreviated according to the following: A-The Antichrist (Nietzsche 1968a), BGE-Beyond Good and Evil (Nietzsche 2000a), CW-The Case of Wagner (Nietzsche 2000c), D-Daybreak (Nietzsche 1997), EH-Ecce Homo (Nietzsche 2000d), GM-On the Genealogy of Morals (Nietzsche 2000b), HH-Human, all too Human (1996), TI-Twilight of the Idols (Nietzsche 1968c), and Z-Thus Spoke Zarathustra (Nietzsche 1968b). References for all passages will use section titles and/or section numbers rather than page numbers.…”