Can ChatGPT Enhance Chemistry Laboratory Teaching? Using Prompt Engineering to Enable AI in Generating Laboratory Activities

Abstract

The rapid evolution of Artificial Intelligence (AI) is profoundly shaping our society. Among various AI tools, ChatGPT stands out for its user-friendly nature and wide accessibility to the public. However, despite their countless potential benefits, these tools also face significant challenges, especially in sensitive areas like Education. In this publication, we conduct a prompt engineering essay with ChatGPT to understand the potential and challenges of this tool in designing new, high-quality chemistry laboratory activities. We aimed to assess its performance in proposing scientifically and pedagogically suitable protocols for chemistry laboratory activities based on the 11thgrade Portuguese curriculum. The initial exploratory essay was conducted to fine-tune the prompt, followed by the analysis of proposals for the five mandatory laboratory activities in this subject. ChatGPT demonstrates the ability to interpret and reproduce the specialized symbolic language of chemistry, effectively conceptualizing problems and laboratory activities in a clear and understandable manner for a broader audience (i.e., chemistry students). However, it is crucial to highlight the scientific-pedagogical limitations concerning the accuracy and appropriateness of the proposed laboratory activities, particularly in terms of safety and sustainability. Therefore, the use of AI in education should be approached critically and reflectively. While AI holds immense potential to transform the dynamics of teaching and learning, the role and expertise of the Chemistry teacher remain of the utmost importance to ensure the scientific and pedagogical quality of Chemistry classes.

Multimodal Generative Artificial Intelligence Tackles Visual Problems in Chemistry

“…Researchers and practitioners are encouraged to become proficient in prompting techniques, as mastering these can greatly enhance outputs’ quality. This exploration is crucial for optimizing the educational potential of AI by tailoring interactions that are not only responsive but also pedagogically valuable. ,,,− …”

Large Language Models are Catalyzing Chemistry Education

“…Following these advances in LLMs and more generally, generative AI, more attention has been paid to education and learning in chemistry [32,33,34,35]. Promising potential applications have been discussed and implemented [36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43], that highlight promising opportunities while also discussing potential negative effects of already publicly-accessible tools [44,33]. Indeed, authors cite issues such as threats to the traditional essay writing for evaluation of understanding [44], plagiarism concerns [33], and more broadly the effect of Generative AI on student's learning and understanding [45,46,47,48].…”

Using ChatGPT-4 to Teach the Design of Data Visualizations

“…In the Fall of 2023, my course used one of these AI tools (ChatGPT-4) as the predominant means for creating and refining data visualizations, and this manuscript discusses the approach used as well as its relative merits and limitations as well as student perceptions and outcomes. It should be mentioned that there is already significant discussion of the role of AI tools in chemical education, focusing on topics such as writing aids, lesson planning aids, , strengths and shortcomings for problem solving, − concerns over academic integrity, and enhancing student learning activities. ,, However, to my knowledge, there are yet no articles discussing the use of AI to help teach the design of data visualizations. It is hoped the approach discussed below could be incorporated into other courses, thereby better preparing students to effectively communicate their science.…”