Can Emergency Medicine Residents Predict Cost of Diagnostic Testing?

Abstract

IntroductionDiagnostic testing represents a significant portion of healthcare spending, and cost should be considered when ordering such tests. Needless and excessive spending may occur without an appreciation of the impact on the larger healthcare system. Knowledge regarding the cost of diagnostic testing among emergency medicine (EM) residents has not previously been studied.MethodsA survey was administered to 20 EM residents from a single ACGME-accredited three-year EM residency program, asking for an estimation of patient charges for 20 commonly ordered laboratory tests and seven radiological exams. We compared responses between residency classes to evaluate whether there was a difference based on level of training.ResultsThe survey completion rate was 100% (20/20 residents). We noted significant discrepancies between the median resident estimates and actual charge to patient for both laboratory and radiological exams. Nearly all responses were an underestimate of the actual cost. The group median underestimation for laboratory testing was $114, for radiographs $57, and for computed tomography exams was $1,058. There was improvement in accuracy with increasing level of training.ConclusionThis pilot study demonstrates that EM residents have a poor understanding of the charges burdening patients and health insurance providers. In order to make balanced decisions with regard to diagnostic testing, providers must appreciate these factors. Education regarding the cost of providing emergency care is a potential area for improvement of EM residency curricula, and warrants further attention and investigation.

Management of acute diarrhea in the emergency department of a tertiary care university medical center

“…A recent study by Tainter et al demonstrated poor insight by ED residents regarding costs, which increases the economic burden on healthcare systems. 22 Although addressing this issue is not currently applicable to our setting where the cost of a test is not visible to the ordering physician, making costs visible can be easily adopted in ED settings to control the cost of care. Importantly, continuous training and education about the immeasurable damage of the inappropriate use of antibiotics in the community should be prioritized given the increasing rates of antimicrobial resistance worldwide.…”

Clinical utility and economic burden of routine serum lipase determination in the Emergency Department

“…Earlier studies have shown that residents in departments other than ED including paediatrics and internal medicine lack the knowledge about the cost of many tests, and awareness may therefore have a role in improving practice . A recent pilot study by Tainter et al compared responses from residents in the ED demonstrating a very poor insight about costs burdening patients and healthcare plans . Although this might not be applicable to our setting where the cost of a test is visible to the ordering physician, this approach would be useful to adopt in ED settings and healthcare settings in general to control cost of care and unnecessary test utilisation.…”

A five-step program for diagnostic test addiction

“…In today's access-blocked emergency departments (EDs), many tests are ordered by nurses or trainees to expedite patient care. 3,13 These users often have limited experience interpreting test results, scant training in testing theory, and an exaggerated sense of test utility. 13 Our objective is to describe a minimum knowledge set for every clinician who orders tests in the ED, and propose a five-step cognitive tool to apply before ordering tests (Table 1).…”