Can low concentrations of Papain help repair articular cartilage defects?

Abstract

Abstract:In the present study, we investigate the capability of low concentrations of Papain to stimulate cartilage mesenchymal cells proliferation and transformation to chondrocytes and evaluate the healing capability of partial thickness defects in medial condyle cartilage of 30 rabbits' knee joints. Papain 0.1 mg/ml and Ringer saline l ml each were injected intra-articularly to rabbits of experimental and control groups (15 animals each). Healthy cartilage from lateral condyle and cartilage from medial condyle where the surgical defect was created were studied histologically and by TEM. The study revealed that 0.1 mg/ml Papain activates proliferation and spreading of mesenchymal stem cells to young forms of chondrocyte from perichondrium to the upper layers of healthy cartilage. In only 22.27% cases of the experimental group, surgical defects filled with cartilaginous tissue on the background of distinct destruction of collagenous matrix in the native cartilage. However, in 55.5% of the control group the defect was spontaneously healed by hyaline cartilaginous tissue completely or partially on the basis of slight destruction of collagenous matrix. The defect site was filled with activated chondrocyte-like cells from the subchondral plate (not perichondrium) in both groups, which acquired some cisterns of rough endoplasmic reticulum (RER) and produced matrix proteins. The results suggest that Papain did not ameliorate the recovery of cartilage defects acquired through surgically-induced injury of collagenous matrix in native cartilage. We observed that articular cartilage is the source of mesenchymal stem cells which have the ability to transform into young forms of chondrocytes. This transformation process depends on the level of destruction of native cartilage collagen matrix induced by the defect or by Papain.