Can We Foster a Culture of Peer Support and Promote Mental Health in Adolescence Using a Web-Based App? A Control Group Study

Abstract

BackgroundAdolescence with its many transitions is a vulnerable period for the development of mental illnesses. Establishing effective mental health promotion programs for this age group is a challenge crucial to societal health. Programs must account for the specific developmental tasks that adolescents face. Considering peer influence and fostering adolescent autonomy strivings is essential. Participation in a program should be compelling to young people, and their affinity to new technologies offers unprecedented opportunities in this respect.ObjectiveThe Companion App was developed as a Web-based app giving adolescents access to a peer mentoring system and interactive, health-relevant content to foster a positive peer culture among adolescents and thereby strengthen social support and reduce stress.MethodsIn a control group study design, a group of employed (n=546) and unemployed (n=73) adolescents had access to the Companion App during a 10-month period. The intervention was evaluated using a combination of quantitative and qualitative approaches. Linear mixed effects models were used to analyze changes in chronic stress levels and perception of social support. Monthly feedback on the app and qualitative interviews at the end of the study allowed for an in-depth exploration of the adolescents’ perception of the intervention.ResultsAdolescents in the intervention group did not use the Companion App consistently. The intervention had no significant effect on chronic stress levels or the perception of social support. Adolescents reported endorsing the concept of the app and the implementation of a peer mentoring system in particular. However, technical difficulties and insufficiently obvious benefits of using the app impeded more frequent usage.ConclusionsThe Companion Project implemented a theory-driven and innovative approach to mental health promotion in adolescence, taking into account the specifics of this developmental phase. Particularities of the implementation context, technical aspects of the app, and insufficient incentives may have played considerable roles concerning the difficulties of the Companion Project to establish commitment. However, adopting peer mentoring as a strategy and using an app still seems to us a promising approach in mental health promotion in adolescents. Future projects should be careful to invest enough resources into the technical development of an app and consider a large use of incentives to establish commitment. When targeting risk groups, such as unemployed adolescents, it may be expedient to use more structured approaches including face-to-face support.

End User and Implementer Experiences of mHealth Technologies for Noncommunicable Chronic Disease Management in Young Adults: Systematic Review

“…From these, 12 studies were ultimately included [ 30 - 41 ]. Reasons for exclusion included not being a research paper [ 42 ], not being qualitative or having a qualitative component [ 43 - 50 ], investigating the wrong phenomena of interest [ 51 - 53 ], not meeting the definition of mHealth [ 54 , 55 ], the population being outside the target age band [ 19 , 56 - 62 ], and the population being affected by a condition not considered to be a chronic NCD (eg, mHealth promotion interventions with no specific chronic NCD or lifestyle behaviors) [ 63 - 66 ]. Seven studies contributed findings on end users [ 30 , 31 , 33 - 35 , 37 , 39 ], whereas 5 studies [ 32 , 36 , 38 , 40 , 41 ] reported on implementers.…”

The Utility of a Mental Health App in Apprentice Workers: A Pilot Study

“…Previous trials of mental health apps with young people highlight the difficulties in achieving program adherence within this population (37). Despite minimal feedback on ways to improve the app at the conclusion of Study One, the incorporation of elements to improve engagement and completion rates are required, highlighted by the links between completion and symptom change highlighted in Study Two.…”

Integration of eHealth Tools in the Process of Workplace Health Promotion: Proposal for Design and Implementation

“…Including social support in the form of peer mentors can be additionally included in the process to increase participation. Peer mentors can give advice or support healthy behavior with small incentives [ 84 ]. Including an incentive system to increase participation in eHealth programs could be a success factor for increasing participation as well [ 59 , 72 ].…”