Capturing Cultural Differences between UK and Malaysian Drivers to Inform the Design of In-Vehicle Navigation Systems

Abstract

Attending to cultural diversity is important for products and technology intended for global placement, such as automobiles, yet many products (and associated interfaces) lack genuine cultural differentiation. For example, in-vehicle navigation systems are typically identical in form and function across world markets, differing only in the local language and map database. To capture and explore culturally-salient design factors, we utilised a scenario-based design methodology, involving 6 experienced drivers from the UK and Malaysia. Participants were asked to portray their ideal navigation system interface designsby drawing pictograms and devising accompanying spoken messagesto direct drivers along 3 prescribed routes in the UK, Malaysia and Japan. Routes were presented using video and paper maps, with the order of presentation counterbalanced between groups; participants were not told in advance from which country each route was derived. Proposed designs highlight differences at a country level, which are consequently interpreted from a cultural perspective. For example, Malaysian drivers included a higher density of navigational elements in their designs, particularly in their home environment, compared to UK drivers. Malaysian drivers also created more incremental designs, particularly on the approach to a manoeuvre, suggesting a desire for greater navigational support at this point in the journey. Landmarks were consistently incorporated in designs, but differences were noted in cultural salience. Additionally, the phrasing of instructions (e.g. "go straight on"), nomenclature for road elements (e.g. 'roundabout') and distance declaration conventions (e.g. units) differed at a country level. The findings can be used to inform the design of culturally-attuned in-vehicle navigation systems.

Evaluating secondary input devices to support an automotive touchscreen HMI: A cross-cultural simulator study conducted in the UK and China

“…In a cultural driving context, there is some evidence that questionnaires and 'paper-based' approaches have been employed to elicit culturally-relevant user requirements and preferences, which could be applied to devices and interfaces intended for deployment within vehicles (e.g. Large et al, 2017;Olaverri-Monreal and Bengler, 2011;Young et al, 2012). Nevertheless, self-reported questionnaires are notoriously contextual and responses may be subject to biases, particularly in a cross-cultural context, where one of the cultural groups being studied could be prone to a certain response-set bias (e.g.…”

Driver perceptions of advanced driver assistance systems: A case study

“…In recent years, automobile manufacturers have provided in-vehicle or pre-installed Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS) and parking control 2 to support three types of driving tasks: navigation, manoeuvring, and vehicle stabilisation. These systems were typically developed for the global market without considering cultural differentiation, influencing drivers' attitudes and acceptance 3 . The perception of new technology will naturally vary depending on locality, and it is primarily dictated by individual-level factors such as age, experience and knowledge of the technology 4 .…”