“…In fact, in carbothermal reduction of titania without nitrogen, conversion of Ti 2 O 3 to TiO x C y was the slowest stage, whereas in the presence of nitrogen, fast conversion of Ti 2 O 3 to TiO x C y N z left conversion of Ti 3 O 5 to Ti 2 O 3 as the slowest. Formation of titanium oxycarbonitride in carbothermal reduction in the presence of nitrogen, observed in this work, was in disagreement with the conclusion by Jha and Yoon 4 that titanium carbonitride was the resulting phase formed in the carbothermal reduction/nitridation of titania at 1200°C-1500°C, and with White et al 14 and Ortega et al 15 who reported formation of TiN. The conclusion that titanium nitride or carbonitride formed was based on the XRD analysis; however, titanium carbonitride, nitride, and oxycarbonitride have the same crystal structure (cubic) with very close crystal parameters.…”