Cardiovascular Demands of Deer Retrieval Methods

Abstract

The results of this study suggest towing a deer with a shoulder harness results in significant reductions in CV demand and lower perceived exertion compared with traditional deer dragging techniques. Deer hunters who are deconditioned or have CV risk factors are strongly encouraged to consider deer retrieval methods utilizing a shoulder harness and tow rope to mitigate the increased demands commonly found with traditional retrieval methods.

Electrocardiographic Responses to Deer Hunting in Men and Women

“…In the present study, only 4 hunters dragged a deer, so the physiologic data available for this hunting activity are limited. Only 1 of the 4 hunters achieved an HR indicative of high-intensity exercise (91% HRmax), which is in conflict with other published reports of both simulated 9 ,10,15 and actual 8 hunts. In our prior study, 14 of 15 young, healthy adults achieved an HR ≥85% HRmax while dragging a 56-kg fake deer.…”

“…Our findings are consistent with the limited evidence available from previous studies that suggest deer hunting is a high-intensity physical activity creating an increased demand on the cardiovascular system and potential risk for a cardiac event. [8][9][10]15 In the current investigation, men and women with and without CVD recorded substantial increases in HR and clinically relevant arrhythmias while deer hunting. Hunting activities elicited HR responses Z85% HRmax, demonstrating deer hunting includes high-intensity activity and increased cardiovascular demand.…”

“…Our findings are consistent with the limited evidence available from previous studies that suggest deer hunting is a high-intensity physical activity creating an increased demand on the cardiovascular system and potential risk for a cardiac event. 8 –10,15…”

“…Moreover, our subjects did not record specific weather conditions or terrain in their diaries during their respective hunts. Although previous research shows that dragging a deer in a controlled environment still produces HRs indicative of high-intensity exercise, 15 it could be valuable to examine the additional effect of differing weather conditions and terrain on all phases of the hunt. Finally, our small sample size led to limitations with regard to generalizability of our findings.…”