‘Care Under Pressure’: a realist review of interventions to tackle doctors’ mental ill-health and its impacts on the clinical workforce and patient care

Abstract

IntroductionMental ill-health is prevalent across all groups of health professionals and this is of great concern in many countries. In the UK, the mental health of the National Health Service (NHS) workforce is a major healthcare issue, leading to presenteeism, absenteeism and loss of staff from the workforce. Most interventions targeting doctors aim to increase their ‘productivity’ and ‘resilience’, placing responsibility for good mental health with doctors themselves and neglecting the organisational and structural contexts that may have a detrimental effect on doctors’ well-being. There is a need for approaches that are sensitive to the contextual complexities of mental ill-health in doctors, and that do not treat doctors as a uniform body, but allow distinctions to account for particular characteristics, such as specialty, career stage and different working environments.Methods and analysisOur project aims to understand how, why and in what contexts support interventions can be designed to minimise the incidence of doctors’ mental ill-health. We will conduct a realist review—a form of theory-driven interpretative systematic review—of interventions, drawing on diverse literature sources. The review will iteratively progress through five steps: (1) locate existing theories; (2) search for evidence; (3) select articles; (4) extract and organise data and (5) synthesise evidence and draw conclusions. The analysis will summarise how, why and in what circumstances doctors’ mental ill-health is likely to develop and what can remediate the situation. Throughout the project, we will also engage iteratively with diverse stakeholders in order to produce actionable theory.Ethics and disseminationEthical approval is not required for our review. Our dissemination strategy will be participatory. Tailored outputs will be targeted to: policy makers; NHS employers and healthcare leaders; team leaders; support organisations; doctors experiencing mental ill-health, their families and colleagues.PROSPERO registration numberCRD42017069870.

Mental Health of Clinical Staff Working in High-Risk Epidemic and Pandemic Health Emergencies: A Rapid Review of the Evidence and Meta-Analysis

“…However, because these are means of above cut-off prevalences where studies have used different cut-offs it is not clear what an additional 7.57% of prevalence represents in terms of severity. Meta-analytic estimate of the effect of exposure on acute mental health outcomes Given that high rates of poor mental health are common in staff working in acute medicine (Carrieri et al, 2018;He et al, 2020;Su et al, 2009) we attempted to estimate the additional impact of working in high exposure roles. Meta-analytic estimates of impact of working in high exposure roles are presented in Figure 2 (anxiety symptom measures), Figure 3 (PTSD symptom measures) and Figure 4 (depression symptom measures).…”

Work‐related post‐traumatic stress symptoms in obstetricians and gynaecologists: findings from INDIGO, a mixed‐methods study with a cross‐sectional survey and in‐depth interviews

“…Future research needs to systematically evaluate the implementation of such systems of support in aiming to prevent the experience of traumatic events leading to PTSD and in turn burnout, stress‐related sickness and/or attrition from training. Reviews of organisational change strategies, which have considered the development of trauma‐informed workforces have aimed to change at client‐care level rather than directed at staff themselves. There is a gap in evidence for what works, which now needs to be addressed.…”

Rethinking Health Care Ethics

“…A great mentor, like her, sees you and treats you like a whole person. Carrieri, D., Briscoe, S., Jackson, M., Mattick, K., Papoutsi, C., Pearson, M., et al (2018). 'Care under pressure': A realist review of interventions to tackle doctors' mental ill-health and its impacts on the clinical workforce and patient care.…”