Caregiver-Physician Medication Concordance and Undertreatment of Asthma Among Inner-City Children

Abstract

ABSTRACT. Objective. To assess the extent to which caregivers and their child's physician agree about the prescribed asthma medication regimen and evaluate factors associated with medication concordance.Methods. A cross-sectional, descriptive survey was administered to 318 caregivers of inner-city children with asthma, aged 5 to 12 years, and their caregiver-identified primary care physician at elementary schools and participants' homes. Concordance between caregiver-and physician-reported controller medication prescription was measured.Results. Only 42% of physicians and 32% of caregivers reported a controller medication prescription (78% agreement, ‫؍‬ 0.54; 95% confidence interval: 0.45-0.63) despite that 73% of the children were rated by their caregiver as currently experiencing persistent asthma symptoms. When the physician reported a controller prescription, 38% of the caregivers denied use of a controller. Having a course of oral steroids in the past year ( 2 ‫؍‬ 9.85) and positive caregiver beliefs toward asthma care ( 2 ‫؍‬ 18.40) were associated with caregiver-physician concordance. Multivariate analysis found that when caregivers had high Asthma Beliefs Scale summary scores versus low scores, they were almost 10 times as likely to be concordant with the physician (odds ratio: 9.76; 95% confidence interval: 2.85-33.46).Conclusions. Our data support previous reports of physician underprescribing of controller medication among inner-city children. However, even when prescribed by a physician, more than one third of caregivers did not report a controller prescription, and this discordance was related to caregivers' beliefs about treatment. Efforts to improve physician adherence to asthma guidelines will not result in proper treatment unless caregiver-physician communication about asthma therapy is improved. Pediatrics 2003;111:e214 -e220. URL: http://www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/111/3/e214; attitudes, beliefs, adherence, compliance.

Reducing asthma health disparities in poor Puerto Rican children: The effectiveness of a culturally tailored family intervention

“…There are a number of possible explanations for this inconsistency. Studies have found that parent reports of medication use and adherence are often inaccurate 29 ; therefore our failure to find an association between medication use and symptoms may reflect measurement error. An additional possibility is that parents learned other asthma management strategies (ie, environmental control, symptom monitoring, and so forth) or gained self-efficacy in managing asthma at home that resulted in reduced health care utilization.…”

Effect of parental knowledge and attitude in the control of childhood asthma

“…This stems from the belief that asthma is absent if overt symptoms are absent. 7,8 Another example is parental concern about dependency and addiction towards anti-asthma medication and this may lead to discontinuation of medications. 9 Knowledge about asthma is varied among the public.…”

Improving adherence in paediatric respiratory disease

“…if they are in concordance), patients are more likely to adhere to the agreed treatment regimen, in particular if this takes their views, preferences and context into account [5,9]. Thus, while concordance is related to adherence [10], it does not ensure it, as there may be numerous other issues interfering with adherence [11].…”