Caring and Dominance Affect Participants’ Perceptions and Behaviors During a Virtual Medical Visit

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Physician communication style affects patients' perceptions and behaviors. Two aspects of physician communication style, caring and dominance, are often related in that a high caring physician is usually not dominant and vice versa.OBJECTIVE: This research was aimed at testing the sole or joint impact of physician caring and physician dominance on participant perceptions and behavior during the medical visit. PARTICIPANTS AND DESIGN:In an experimental design, analog patients (APs) (167 university students) interacted with a computer-generated virtual physician on a computer screen. Participants were randomly assigned to 1 of 4 experimental conditions (physician communication style: high dominance and low caring, high dominance and high caring, low dominance and low caring, or low dominance and high caring). The APs' verbal and nonverbal behavior during the visit as well as their perception of the virtual physician were assessed. RESULTS: Analog patients were able to distinguish dominance and caring dimensions of the virtual physician's communication. Moreover, APs provided less medical information, spoke less, and agreed more when interacting with a high-dominant compared to a lowdominant physician. They also talked more about emotions and were quicker in taking their turn to speak when interacting with a high-caring compared to a lowcaring physician.CONCLUSIONS: Dominant and caring physicians elicit different emotional and behavioral responses from APs. Physician dominance reduces patient engagement in the medical dialog and produces submissiveness, whereas physician caring increases patient emotionality.

How Cardiologists Present the Benefits of Percutaneous Coronary Interventions to Patients With Stable Angina

“…Physician dominance may explain, in part, why patients in this study were passive. 41 Use of decision aids can promote shared decision making, and such aids exist for deciding about PCI for stable angina. 42 However, these decision aids are used infrequently.…”

Nonverbal communication and conversational contribution in breast cancer genetic counseling

“…If the counselor is verbally dominant little room is left for counselees to ask questions and initiate discussions on topics of counselees' interest. Verbal dominance may have led to counselee submissiveness and reduced engagement [49] with heightened anxiety as a consequence. However, a previous study found that counselors provided more information to counselees in higher need for emotional support [24].…”

20 Power, dominance, and persuasion

“…In the field of physician-patient communication, physician nonverbal dominance (e.g., talking more, adopting a dominant tone of voice) has been related to lower patient satisfaction (Bertakis, Roter, and Putnam 1991;Burgoon et al 1987;Hall et al 1994), and especially when nonverbal dominance is expressed by female physicians (Schmid Mast, Hall, and Roter 2008).…”

“…For instance, nonverbal dominance of the interaction partner affects an individual's own dominance reactions. Two individuals interacting with each other generally achieve contrast in their dominance behaviors: If A behaves in a high dominant way, B is likely to behave in a less dominant way (Sadler et al 2009;Schmid Mast, Hall, and Roter 2008;Tiedens and Fragale 2003). Interactional and situational characteristics must be taken into account as well when studying expressed and perceived verticality.…”