CARL Libraries – a Canadian resource-sharing experience

Jong, C J de; Frederiksen, Linda

doi:10.1108/ilds-06-2014-0029

Cited by 5 publications

(4 citation statements)

References 24 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…These results are at odds with Webster and Moyo (2016), and Dean (2017) who suggested that the usage of ILL increased because of the convergence of the three events. However, these results are at variance with Kelsall and Onyszko (2010), Raubenheimer and Van Niekerk (2015), Panda and Mallappa (2015), De Jong and Frederiksen (2015), Foran, (2015a), Stapel (2016), Yi (2016), Chalhoub (2017) who determined that ILL requests in Canada, South Africa, India and Netherlands declined but at odds with Fraser et al (2011) who noticed a substantial increase at a university in the Caribbean. Further, the results are at variance with Kilpatrick and Preece (1996), Calvert and Fleming (2013) and Nash and McElfresh (2016) in that the budget cuts do not seem to have a substantial effect on ILL activities.…”

Section: Findings and Discussionmentioning

confidence: 85%

“…Yi (2016) concluded that the decrease was because of the proliferation of open access journals and institutional repositories (IRs) in Korea and globally. Other studies reported decreased use of ILL services (De Jong and Frederiksen, 2015; Foran, 2015a, Chalhoub, 2017). These studies also attributed the decreased demand for ILL services to open access journals and IRs.…”

Section: Literature Reviewmentioning

confidence: 92%

See 1 more Smart Citation

An analysis of interlibrary loan services: a case study of a university in South Africa

Bangani

Chizwina

Moyo

2018

IDD

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Purpose The landscape of teaching, learning and research has changed requiring the need for diverse information resources. Given the current budgetary constraints and financial conditions prevailing in many universities, sharing of information resources has become a necessity. The Interlibrary Loan (ILL) services have thus become an important service to meet the immediate needs of library users. The aim of this paper is to analyse the ILL services of the North-West University in South Africa from 2006 to 2016. Using statistical data, the paper shows the emerging pattern in borrowing and lending between institutions as well as determines the existence of correlations between borrowing and lending libraries. The results of this study show that ILL amongst libraries has decreased in the past 11 years. A need exists for increased awareness of ILL and there is need for technological innovations that will ensure that library users are able to request for information resources seamlessly. Design/methodology/approach This is a quantitative study that uses ILL data from the North-West University. Data were downloaded from the SABINET ILL system using the three NWU JC codes. They were then collated and uploaded on excel spreadsheets. In the main, the excel spreadsheets were used to interpret the data. Further, the Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) software, in particular Spearman’s Correlation Analysis, was used to test correlations between data from libraries that requested information resources from NWU and data from libraries that supplied information resources to NWU during this period using Rumsey’s guidelines to interpret the correlations. Findings The findings of the study reveal that ILL among libraries in South Africa had generally declined owing mostly to the proliferation of online resources resulting to changes in user information-seeking behaviour. The decline is despite the challenges of low budgets received by most libraries for the acquisition of information resources. It can also be concluded that public university libraries still value ILL as demonstrated by the high number of items requested from other libraries. The findings also reveal that most ILL activities were conducted by public universities. Research limitations/implications It was not possible to obtain the list of titles that have been requested and also to obtain the user’s details. This would have enabled the authors to determine the type of titles that are being requested, and the users that request them. Practical implications ILL should continue to be enhanced in view of the challenge of dwindling library budgets against the escalating prices of information resources. There is also a need for user education so that they become aware of the ILL service. From experience, library users normally give up once they realize that what they wanted is not available through the local catalogue and this calls for librarians to create an awareness to users that ILL could help solve their frustrations. Social implications These results show that ILL can play a significant role to level the playing field between the well-resourced libraries in urbanized regions or provinces and the poorly resourced ones in rural regions or provinces. This social justice aspect of ILL is probably the reason why better resourced libraries in South Africa have decided to remain in the scheme unlike other countries where better resourced libraries opted out of reciprocal arrangements with small and medium-sized institutions. Originality/value The study adds to a very limited number of studies emanating from Africa. A study of this nature has never been conducted in Africa, as previous studies were nationwide studies. As far as the authors know, this is the first study that uses ILL data to research the impact of the global financial crisis on libraries in Africa.

show abstract

Section: Findings and Discussionmentioning

confidence: 85%

Section: Literature Reviewmentioning

confidence: 92%

An analysis of interlibrary loan services: a case study of a university in South Africa

Bangani

Chizwina

Moyo

2018

IDD

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…It has wide applications in natural language processing. It is necessary to convert a document to a vector, namely, mapping the documents (de Jong and Frederiksen, 2015) in the vector space, then use the vector calculation to compute the distance between the vectors. Generally speaking, the key to establish VSM is to determine the dimension, which is known as an item.…”

Section: Vector Space Modelmentioning

confidence: 99%

The uncertainty mapping of ontologies based on three-dimensional combination weight vector space model

Han

Wang

Luo

et al. 2018

IDD

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Purpose This paper aims to apply vector space model (VSM)-PCR model to compute the similarity of Fault zone ontology semantics, which verified the feasibility and effectiveness of the application of VSM-PCR method in uncertainty mapping of ontologies. Design/methodology/approach The authors first define the concept of uncertainty ontology and then propose the method of ontology mapping. The proposed method fully considers the properties of ontology in measuring the similarity of concept. It expands the single VSM of concept meaning or instance set to the “meaning, properties, instance” three-dimensional VSM and uses membership degree or correlation to express the level of uncertainty. Findings It provides a relatively better accuracy which verified the feasibility and effectiveness of VSM-PCR method in treating the uncertainty mapping of ontology. Research limitations/implications The future work will focus on exploring the similarity measure and combinational methods in every dimension. Originality/value This paper presents an uncertain mapping method of ontology concept based on three-dimensional combination weighted VSM, namely, VSM-PCR. It expands the single VSM of concept meaning or instance set to the “meaning, properties, instance” three-dimensional VSM. The model uses membership degree or correlation which is used to express the degree of uncertainty; as a result, a three-dimensional VSM is obtained. The authors finally provide an example to verify the feasibility and effectiveness of VSM-PCR method in treating the uncertainty mapping of ontology.

show abstract

“…Canadian resource sharing is viewed through the prism of the Canadian Association Research Libraries and a case study of ILL at the University of Alberta. The crucial role of the Canadian National Site Licensing Project in the decline of ILL requesting in 2005 is identified and there is much of interest -especially perhaps in comparing and contrasting the experience of its big neighbour -the USA, (de Jong and Frederiksen, 2015).…”

Section: Resource Sharingmentioning

confidence: 99%

Interlending and document supply: a review of the recent literature: 90

McGrath

2015

Interlending &Amp; Document Supply

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Purpose – This paper aims to review the current LIS literature for document supply, resource sharing and other issues such as open access that have an impact on the service. Design/methodology/approach – The approach is based on the scanning of about 150 journals, reports, websites and blogs. Findings – Important changes are taking place at the British Library. The new (4th) edition of the STM report is well worth reading. Much again, on open access, particularly the high costs of Gold. Elsevier comes in for some more bad press. Originality/value – The only regular literature review that focuses on interlending, document supply and related issues.

show abstract

CARL Libraries – a Canadian resource-sharing experience

Cited by 5 publications

References 24 publications

An analysis of interlibrary loan services: a case study of a university in South Africa

An analysis of interlibrary loan services: a case study of a university in South Africa

The uncertainty mapping of ontologies based on three-dimensional combination weight vector space model

Interlending and document supply: a review of the recent literature: 90

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About