“…Consequently, we observed the enantioselective formation of C 2 -symmetric secondary amine products, instead of the desired primary amines. 10 We speculated that if N-H imine hydrochloride salts would be used instead of the free imines, the corresponding ammonium salt products should not engage in the transimination, thereby potentially preventing the reductive dimerization. However, while anion-binding catalysis has shown utility in addition reactions to iminium salt equivalents, 11 the introduction of a stoichiometric, achiral anion (i.e., Cl -) renders such a reaction design highly challenging, as the underlying principle of asymmetric-counteranion-directed catalysis (ACDC) 12 is undermined.…”