The persistent lack of circular, scalable, and low-impact solutions for decommissioned wind blades remains a challenge for the wind energy sector. With a saturation of proposed technologies, the sector needs to focus efforts on pulling through technologies both for the immediate and longer-term wind blade waste streams. In this work, models for high-profile EoL scenarios have been developed and, using lifecycle assessment, applied to representative onshore and offshore wind blade designs. In their current iterations, not all composite recycling approaches are environmentally beneficial when considering global warming potential (GWP). This is the case particularly for blades consisting of only glass fibre reinforcement, where only cement kiln and mechanical recycling scenarios resulted in GWP lower than landfilling. The introduction of carbon fibre reinforcement leads to reductions in GWP for almost all end-of-life scenarios, the most significant of which coming in the chemical and thermal scenarios. This indicates that to minimise carbon footprint a combination of approaches is required. These findings have been coupled with material circularity indicators and show that, while recycling can be beneficial, it is only one piece of the puzzle. Methods for integrating restorative materials into wind turbine blade designs, as well as finding circular solutions to reduce waste associated with current blade manufacturing practices, are also critical areas of research needed to mitigate the impact of future blade production.