Introduction Lumbar disc herniation during pregnancy poses a significant challenge to the spine surgeon towards achieving good clinical, maternal, and fetal outcomes. Surgical intervention is warranted in patients with significant neural deficits, and cauda equina syndrome and needs to be performed at the earliest in order to avoid irreversible neurological sequelae. Case presentation We report a 29-year-old primigravida in her 21st week of gestational period, who was diagnosed with cauda equina syndrome secondary to two level lumbar disc herniations. The lengthier surgical duration in performing double level disc herniations in an obese patient raises concerns in anesthetic dosing of drugs and surgical positioning which may result in fetal distress. A double level decompression and discectomy in prone position was done under general anesthesia. Despite the surgical challenges, the postoperative period was uneventful resulting in immediate pain relief and complete neurological recovery, followed by the delivery of a 2.7-kg healthy male child. Discussion Surgical intervention can be performed in pregnancy, to avoid irreversible neurological deficits, even in an obese individual with double level lumbar pathology. However, it is essential that the surgeon appraises the situation and involves an integrated multidisciplinary team comprising anesthetist, spine surgeon, obstetrician, and psychologist, and inculcates certain precautions in the perioperative management to achieve good surgical and fetal outcomes.