Caught between a rock and a hard place: mental health of migrant live-in caregivers in Canada

Abstract

BackgroundCanada depends on Temporary Foreign Workers (TFWs), also known as migrant workers, to fill labour shortage in agriculture, hospitality, construction, child/senior care, and other low-skilled occupations. Evidence shows that TFWs, especially women live-in caregivers (LC), constitute a vulnerable population. Their health is compromised by the precarious and harsh working and living conditions they encounter. There is a paucity of research on the mental health of LCs, their support systems and access to mental health services.MethodIn this community-based exploratory study, we used mixed methods of survey and focus groups to explore the work related experiences and mental health of migrant live-in caregivers in the Greater Toronto Area in Ontario, Canada. Convenience and snowball sampling were used to recruit participants. The inclusion criteria were: being 18 years or older, initially migrated to Canada as TFWs under LC program, resided in the Greater Toronto Area, and able to understand and converse in English based on self-report. This paper reports on the focus group results derived from inductive thematic analysis.ResultsA total of 30 women LCs participated in the study. Most of them were from the Philippines. A number of key themes emerged from the participants’ narratives: (1) precarious migration-employment status (re)produces exploitation; (2) deskilling and downward social mobility reinforce alienation; (3) endurance of hardship for family back home; (4) double lives of public cheerfulness and private anguish; and (4) unrecognized mental health needs. The study results reflected gross injustices experienced by these women.ConclusionA multi-faceted approach is required to improve the working and living conditions of this vulnerable group and ultimately their health outcomes. We recommend the following: government inspection to ensure employer compliance with the labour standards and provision of safe working and living conditions; change immigration policy to allow migrant caregivers to apply for permanent residence upon arrival; the TFWs Program to establish fair wages and subsidized housing so that caregivers can truly access the live-out option; and local ethno-specific, settlement and faith organizations be leveraged to provide TFWs with social support as well as information about their rights and how to access health and social care.

Migrant Workers and Psychological Health: A Systematic Review

“…The personal characteristics of the migrant workers, such as the gender, can increase the risk of developing mental problems. While work-related injuries are more common in male migrants due to heavier and more dangerous jobs, regarding mental health, women are more stressed because of their distance from the family, caregiver jobs, and the greater frequency of harassment [133]. Migrant workers often leave home to ensure greater economic income for their families.…”

Psychosocial Risk Prevention in a Global Occupational Health Perspective. A Descriptive Analysis

“…In 2015, the migrant population represented nearly 4% of the total global population aged 15 years and over and cannot be neglected [64]. This leads, furthermore, to the need to homogenise the legislative tools to address psychosocial hazards in all countries.…”

Major Depressive Syndrome (MDS) and its Association with Time of Residence among Spanish Speaking Au-Pairs Living in Germany

“…Hence, in cases of poor working conditions or even violence, it is difficult for au-pairs to change or improve their situation because their living place and residence permits are tied to the host families [5,6]. In addition, living and working in the same place might lead to lose boundaries between working and free time [13].…”

“…Often, they even are healthier than local born residents in the host country. Then, according to the second phenomenon, progressively this advantage declines or even disappears over a relatively short period [12,13].…”