Caught in a trap? Financial Fair Play Regulations and the case of Scottish football

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this study is to investigate the Union of European Football Associations’s Financial Fair Play (FFP) Regulations in the context of the European football industry. This study seeks to explore whether these regulations are perceived by member organisations as contributing to the creation of a “poverty trap”. To do so, this study turns towards what are traditionally perceived as smaller clubs operating in smaller member associations and, in doing so, explores whether the regulations limiting benefactor payments are suitable for smaller leagues. Design/methodology/approach In-depth semi-structured interviews were conducted with key individuals involved in the management of Scottish football clubs. The Scottish context was chosen because of the disparity in revenues amongst competing teams and the limited broadcasting revenues achieved in comparison to some other European member associations. Findings FFP Regulations are perceived to be an effective tool for monitoring clubs and ensuring financial stability. However, the findings suggest that participants believe that these regulations consolidate the financial position of larger teams who rely on broadcasting and extant brand power for revenue generation. Further, smaller leagues demonstrate a lesser reliance on benefactor payments, and therefore, the restriction on benefactor payments inherent within FFP Regulations is posited by participants as holding little consequence and/or relevance within the Scottish football context. Originality/value Most prior studies on FFP Regulations have focused on generating quantitative insight into the application of FFP Regulations in large, resource-rich European football leagues. Through a qualitative approach, this study provides nascent exploratory insight into FFP Regulations from the perspective of smaller leagues.

The effects of participation in European competitions on the domestic competitiveness of Polish football clubs

“…However, the experience and fees from the UEFA are not sufficient to gain a lasting advantage in the domestic market and cover the potential loss of the most effective players being transferred out as a result of their increased profile during the European cups. This is how the 'poverty trap', in which football clubs' governing bodies believe in, works in practice (Maclean et al, 2022). However, the question remains as to whether this trap is inevitable or results from the ineffective management of professional football clubs in the Polish context.…”

“…The described changes have led to an increase in inequality not only at the international level but also domestically, where the biggest clubs have enhanced domination in the league competition (Norbäck et al, 2021;Pawlowski et al, 2010). According to Maclean et al (2022), board managers of Scottish football clubs share this viewpoint, as they believe that the introduction of FFP creates a 'poverty trap' for smaller teams. Researchers (e.g.…”

Analyzing the champions league teams via decision models

“…Additionally, Financial Fair Play might only protect bigger teams in richer and more prestigious European competitions. In contrast to traditionally smaller, less-established clubs, these clubs tend to be more successful on and off the field, and as a result, are able to generate significant supplemental income through increasingly lucrative sponsorship deals and commercial partnerships, along with competition prize money (Maclean et al , 2022). Real Madrid, which obtains financial and sportive performance is a good example in this regard.…”

The impact of financial fair play on the financial performance of Spanish professional football: do the biggest clubs behave better?

“…Extant empirical evidence has centred on a single European league (e.g. Maclean et al, 2022;Perechuda and Cater, 2022) or several leagues together, focusing on the Big Five leagues, English Premier League (EPL), Spanish LaLiga, German Bundesliga, Italian Serie A and French Ligue1 (e.g. Perechuda, 2020;Ruta et al, 2022).…”