Feline cutaneous mast cell tumors (MCTs) have been histologically classified as mastocytic (well differentiated or pleomorphic) and atypical/poorly granulated. Their biologic behavior ranges from benign to malignant, but prognostic factors are not well defined. Histologic classification, number of tumors, mitotic index, cytoplasmic granularity, and infiltration by eosinophils or lymphocytes were evaluated retrospectively in 25 feline cutaneous MCTs. Immunohistochemistry was applied to assess KIT (CD117) pattern and immunoreactivity score, telomerase expression (human telomerase reverse transcriptase), and proliferation index (MIB-1/Ki67 index). Case outcome was obtained via telephone interviews. The tumors comprised 15 mastocytic well-differentiated, 7 mastocytic pleomorphic, and 3 atypical/poorly granulated MCTs. Immunohistochemically, CD117 was expressed in 13 of 25 tumors (52%), and telomerase reverse transcriptase was expressed in 15 of 22 (68%), with no correlation to histologic classification. Mitotic index, KIT immunoreactivity score, and Ki67 index were significantly higher in mastocytic pleomorphic MCTs than in the other 2 categories. Five cats (20%) died of tumor-related causes. Multiplicity of lesions, pleomorphic phenotype, KIT immunoreactivity score, and mitotic and Ki67-indices correlated with an unfavorable outcome. Mitotic index was the strongest predictive variable. These results suggest that histologic classification, CD117/KIT immunohistochemistry, and proliferation indices may help to identify potentially aggressive cases of feline cutaneous MCT. Aberrant KIT protein localization and telomerase immunoreactivity warrant further exploration as potential prognostic markers.