Regulatory T cells (Treg) play crucial roles in regulating autoimmune responses and immunity to tumors and infectious diseases. However, numerous subpopulations of Treg are now being described and the utility of various Treg markers is being reassessed. Here we report the results of a detailed phenotypic comparison of two supposedly regulatory human T-cell populations, namely CD4
1
FOXP31 T cells and CD4 (CCR), CD95 and Bcl-2, suggestive of distinct migration characteristics and susceptibility to apoptosis. Further, we propose that CD25 expression should be regarded as an activation marker rather than as a defining marker of Treg. Lastly, CD4 1 FOXP3 1 T cells activated in vitro with malaria antigen expressed the highest levels of CCR4 and CD95, and the lowest levels of CCR7, indicating that they are most likely generated from effector memory cells during an immune response and rapidly succumb to apoptosis at the end of the response. [7]. A plethora of different regulatory mechanisms has been identified (reviewed by [8]). With such a broad range of effects and mechanisms of action, it seems plausible that different subsets of natural Treg may exist. Indeed, it is increasingly recognised that human Treg are far more heterogenous than murine Treg [9], and that even CD4 [37]. Functionally distinct Treg subpopulations have also been identified on the basis of forkhead box P3 (FOXP3) expression intensity and CD45RA expression [10].We have previously reported that in areas of seasonal malaria transmission, Treg may expand alongside effector memory (EM) T cells when malaria exposure is high, and that both populations may contract once exposure decreases [38]; this contraction may involve apoptotic pathways. Treg have been shown to be highly susceptible to spontaneous cell death or cytokine-deprivation induced death [39]. As for conventional T cells, it has been shown that the majority of CD4 T cells with regard to the expression of CCR and apoptotic molecules and suggest that CD25, rather than being a marker of Treg per se, is a marker of activated Treg. Given our interest in Treg function during malaria infection [38,[44][45][46][47], we further aimed to study these markers in relation to Treg activation status in vitro, using Plasmodium falciparum schizont extract (PfSE). Importantly, we show that -irrespective of the culture conditions -the phenotype of FOXP3 1 T cells is modified when they are kept in in vitro culture, affecting both expression of CCR and molecules involved in apoptosis, indicating a need for caution when comparing data from in vitro and ex vivo studies.
Results
CD25 -a Treg-identifying marker or a marker of Treg activation?Whole blood from 28 adult Gambian donors was stained ex vivo and viable lymphocytes were gated for CD4 and CD25 expression.The double negative (CD4 -CD25 -) population was used to define the cut-off for CD4 and CD25 expression (Fig. 1A) (Fig. 2D) and expressing significantly higher levels of CD95 than the CD25 -or CD25 lo populations (Fig. 2E). However, importantly, both the l...